The fact that the package hasn't been sent for 8 days was a mistake (bad, bad seller!) ;-), however one should ask himself...what kind of a buyer requests a PayPal claim after only 8 days? Has he tried to contact you by e-mail during that time? No? An Amiga user that's a judge in NYC? More like a high school kid trying to pull an internet fraud, in my opinion (repeat, in my opinion...I'm only speculating on a hunch).
This looks like a fraud to me.
The mind of a kid fraudster ---> If I tell him that I'm a judge, he'll surely steer clear from this issue as he wouldn't want an angry judge on his back, would he now?