@ mikeymike
He asked you were your accusation came from...
Ikir's statement was non specific, so IMO only if a person is in fact a troll, this person should feel that this applies to him- or herself and there may be a need to defend oneself. :-P
Personally I could list a few dozen claims by various people who had claimed it to be a fact that the involved companies or the AmigaOS4 product itself was doomed for failure.
I agree that it's good to see those trolls being proven more and more wrong on a near weekly basis. 8-) Although I don't think it's a good idea to start finger pointing at specific individuals and cause yet another flamewar.