Aha, that may be the problem since I do not have the original floppy cable, I am using a PC one as a substitute.
No the floppy is completely dead with or without HD connected. And it shows up as "

" on the desktop if it is connected or not.
I am going to try new cable tomorrow, I have had so much problem with this Amiga, I think it is a good idea if people do not store expensive A4000 towers with PPC cards in a moist cellar :cry: :-)