Odin,
Sorry to hear about your hard drive problems dude.
If it's any help, some drives seem to be prone to corrupting the RDB at the slightest excuse. The most robust HDD I ever had was a 420Mb Western Digital that never let me down once.
I fitted a bigger drive (beyond 4.3 Gig) and sure enough the inevitable happened. Booting up the Amiga would result in a Guru every time until I removed the drive or disabled it in the early startup menu. Didn't matter what filesystem I used either :pissed:
I'll ask a very stupid question.... Did you run a quick format or did you run a full format on the drive when you originally installed it? The stability of the filesystem seems to be much better if you run a full format.
Don't shoot the miggy just yet!