If I'm reading right, it sounds like you have a damaged Mobo. No RGB output even with Indi removed? Honestly I'd try to get that fixed first, before moving on with any other troubleshooting.

Can you test the 2nd Indi with your 1st A1200?
If 2nd Indi works with 1st A1200, you'll know the problem is with 2nd A1200 mobo. If 2nd Indi has the same problem with 1st A1200, you'll know problem is with 2nd Indi. That's like, what I do all day long, man. Swap components until I find ones that work!
