Certainly was a long and interesting read. Thanks for posting.
I always thought Commodore should have been left alone as a company and not been brought back at all.
I also think Amiga would have had more success competing along side Microsoft and Sony as a gaming platform, building on what they started with the CD32. I'd love to own an Amiga gaming console in the same style as the PS3 or X-Box. It would have been up there graphically with the best and would have also provided a platform for all the Amiga projects going on in the community, including retro game emulation.
I find Commodore USA a bit pointless to be honest, and agree that without the Amiga and Commodore labels no-one would even notice them at all, they would just be another online company selling custom built PC's, overpriced ones at that. Nothing Commodore or Amiga about it to be honest.