Amiga.org

Amiga computer related discussion => Amiga Hardware Issues and discussion => Topic started by: lassie on May 19, 2016, 12:49:13 PM

Title: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: lassie on May 19, 2016, 12:49:13 PM
Hello
Do you know if i should have a fan for my apollo 040 when it is in a tower? Or is it ok without fan.
Title: Re: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: jj on May 19, 2016, 12:53:44 PM
It can never hurt to have a fan on an 040 they get pretty hot, but even the desktop accelerators for the A1200 didn't have, and there was no air flow there.

Should be fine in a tower without one.
Title: Re: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: lassie on May 19, 2016, 12:56:09 PM
Quote from: JJ;808762
It can never hurt to have a fan on an 040 they get pretty hot, but even the desktop accelerators for the A1200 didn't have, and there was no air flow there.

Should be fine in a tower without one.


Thanks for answer :-) Many just told me it would crash and burn out. But it try to use it without fan.
Title: Re: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: roomeo on May 19, 2016, 01:03:22 PM
It depends on the 040 revision. Some get hot, some dont..

A fan dont hurt, but you wont destroy your cpu without one.
Title: Re: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: Lord Aga on May 19, 2016, 01:08:56 PM
Is there a good reason why one wouldn't put a silent fan inside a case to at least blow over the hottest spot  ?
Title: Re: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: save2600 on May 19, 2016, 01:24:10 PM
Quote from: Lord Aga;808765
Is there a good reason why one wouldn't put a silent fan inside a case to at least blow over the hottest spot  ?


Fans in computers are used to suck hot air out of the case and allow proper airflow in one way and out the other. If you stick a fan in there to blow on to your components, it'll surely keep things cool, but you're also exponentially adding and trapping dust all over the place. Worse than what already happens in a normal config. I've had configs where I did just that though and is fine so long as you maintain your system. I.e.: open it up and vacuum the dust out regularly. Wouldn't use a can of air spray without a vacuum hose either though. Unless you're fine with blowing dust from one place to another, like your lungs or other parts of the room and computer.   ;)
Title: Re: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: Lord Aga on May 19, 2016, 01:33:58 PM
Wow, that completely obliterated my point. Boy do I feel like a dummy now.
Title: Re: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: klx300r on May 19, 2016, 04:34:37 PM
Quote from: save2600;808766
Fans in computers are used to suck hot air out of the case and allow proper airflow in one way and out the other. If you stick a fan in there to blow on to your components, it'll surely keep things cool, but you're also exponentially adding and trapping dust all over the place. Worse than what already happens in a normal config. I've had configs where I did just that though and is fine so long as you maintain your system. I.e.: open it up and vacuum the dust out regularly. Wouldn't use a can of air spray without a vacuum hose either though. Unless you're fine with blowing dust from one place to another, like your lungs or other parts of the room and computer.   ;)

I'm pretty sure a small fan right above a CPU won't make any difference on case air flow.  The issue I've personally seen that causes havoc with case air flow is when the case fan is sucking air in and out and another (or more) large separate case fans are doing the opposite!

Rule of thumb: make sure your fans are sucking and blowing the same direction (& no I'm not referring to rock band groupies) ;)
Title: Re: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: Oldsmobile_Mike on May 19, 2016, 04:37:21 PM
I would never run a system without heatsinks and fans all over the place. Heat = death, and it's not exactly like our systems are getting any younger, or being made any more, you know? ;)
Title: Re: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: lassie on May 19, 2016, 07:47:56 PM
Hmm what to do, what if i just use max 2 hours at the time until i can see if i can get a fan?
Title: Re: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: Oldsmobile_Mike on May 19, 2016, 07:51:46 PM
Quote from: lassie;808786
Hmm what to do, what if i just use max 2 hours at the time until i can see if i can get a fan?

You've got like, 20 computers in your signature.  Just borrow a fan out of another system if you don't already have one handy.  :laughing:
Title: Re: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: lassie on May 19, 2016, 07:53:48 PM
Quote from: Oldsmobile_Mike;808787
You've got like, 20 computers in your signature.  Just borrow a fan out of another system if you don't already have one handy.  :laughing:


There is only fan in the 4000 and 2000, and those are some big fans, don't think it will fit in this one :-)
Title: Re: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: Lord Aga on May 19, 2016, 09:22:28 PM
Allow me to answer that, for I have seen the light now !

Fans are bad for everyone, mkay? Instead, we should put red-hot soldering irons on our CPUs. Those will, pay attention now, burn the floating dust inside the case. So less dust. Which is all that matters. The CPU wont mind, he's a tough little bugger.

Problem solved.
Title: Re: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: paul1981 on May 20, 2016, 12:14:54 AM
Technically you don't need a fan, but the choice is yours. If it was my CPU, I wouldn't be happy unless there was a heat sink or fan on there. I'd say that any 'sensible' Amiga owner would use one or the other.
Title: Re: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: lassie on May 20, 2016, 12:41:03 AM
Quote from: paul1981;808805
Technically you don't need a fan, but the choice is yours. If it was my CPU, I wouldn't be happy unless there was a heat sink or fan on there. I'd say that any 'sensible' Amiga owner would use one or the other.


Hi
Do you have a link for a heat sink, i might use for it?
Title: Re: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: paul1981 on May 20, 2016, 01:57:35 PM
Quote from: paul1981;808805
Technically you don't need a fan, but the choice is yours. If it was my CPU, I wouldn't be happy unless there was a heat sink or fan on there. I'd say that any 'sensible' Amiga owner would use one or the other.


Quote from: lassie;808806
Hi
Do you have a link for a heat sink, i might use for it?


http://www.amazon.com/Black-Aluminum-Radiator-Heatsink-x11mm/dp/B00REFEQ90/ (http://www.amazon.com/Black-Aluminum-Radiator-Heatsink-x11mm/dp/B00REFEQ90/)

There's thermal conductive sticky pads you could use instead of super glue in the corners and thermal paste - have a look on eBay. The heatsink doesn't have to be large, but put dead in the center. You can buy heatsinks with these sticky thermal pads already attached, just peel back the tape and stick on firmly to get a good thermal connection. These thermal pads are supposedly not as good as the paste, but would be more than sufficient in this case.
Title: Re: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: Iggy on May 20, 2016, 02:17:09 PM
Quote from: Oldsmobile_Mike;808771
I would never run a system without heatsinks and fans all over the place. Heat = death, and it's not exactly like our systems are getting any younger, or being made any more, you know? ;)


I used to think like that too, until I built a few systems that sounded like small jet engines while running (and quieter fans only help so much when you have a lot of them).

But I would at least use the largest heatsink I could fit into the application.
Later '040s do run quite a bit cooler, but why wouldn't you run the risk when a big block of metal is cheap?
Title: Re: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: smerf on May 20, 2016, 09:20:50 PM
Really is cheap insurance, unless you are really taxing your power supply right now. I would install a fan.
Title: Re: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: lassie on May 23, 2016, 08:27:20 PM
Hi
I have order a heat sink and that thermal paste, i hope it will work so it don't get to warm.
Title: Re: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: lassie on June 02, 2016, 12:37:12 PM
Now i have put a heat sink on the Apollo :-) hope it is enough, so it don't get too warm.
Title: Re: Apollo 040 Amiga 1200 tower
Post by: Shamron on June 02, 2016, 04:03:38 PM
Semiconductors at 40 degrees celcius, last infinately longer than semiconductors running at 50 degrees celcius. At 60 degrees, picture a windows file copy progress bar, but instead of copying % complete, picture remaining life expectancy.

I'm making class a amplifiers in my spare time. A 2x15W class a amplifier idles (yes, IDLES) at 2-3 amperes per channel when not playing anything at all. To make ut perfectly clear, when the amplifier is ON, but NOT playing any music out to the speakers, they still draw 2-3 amperes per channel. Just by being switched ON.

As output transistors, i use Mj15003 which can handle 10 amps / 250W. when PROPERLY heatsinked. Same goes for the KBPC3510 Rectifiers. They can handle 35 amperes when heatsinked, and 10 when not. Needless to say, even when half-assed-effortly heatsinked, they reach 80-90 degrees celcius. EASY.

So, what did i do to cool them, and why do i even care?

My amplifier is a standard 42,7CM width, having heatsinks all along the sides. I bought an IKEA table, lifted the bottom shelf, basicly creating a box, sawed two slots the same width and length as the heatsinks, then put two 120mm  fans at the bottom of the "box", sucking cold air in from below, and blowing the air out through the  two slots underneath the heatsinks.

With this solution, i reduced the temperature of the heatsinks from around 75-80 degrees celcius to below 35! Yes, i made my class a amplifier cooler than body temperature, which is hilarious if you either know or read up a bit on class a amplifiers. :-)

So, why did i put so much effort into this?

The 2x15W class a amplifier i use, have 2x100.000uF capacitors. these cost 500 norwegian kroner each (around 90$ each)

The output transistors are genuine and cost 40 nok (around 7$) each.

Also, all the heat from the components mounted on a heatsink that transfers heat into the air, instead of trapping it inside the case, adds to reduced heating costs, instead of adding to repair/replacement costs.

Someone above argued that fans are bad because they INSTANTLY makes 8 BILLION tons of dust, magically appear inside your computer. This is just... no. Just, no.

Someone else argued that fans are bad because people usually put them in opposite ways...

No. Again.. I... no. Just... NO!

Fans don't automatically suck or blow. They do one or the other, based on where you put them and how you connect them.

There's a thing called positive air pressure, which you will get if you got 3 fans sucking cold air in, and 2 fans blowing hot air out. This does in theory prevent dust from gathering inside your computer.

What's a REAL killer though, is having your computer near the kitchen, where you fry and boil whatevere in fat and oil all day long. Good luck getting those fans clean JUST by blowing them with a spray duster...

I digress...

We live on an ever-shrinking island. Every day, there's an %&$#?@!%&$#?@!%&$#?@!%&$#?@!%&$#?@!%&$#?@!%&$#?@!, being bored and overclocking his Amiga, pushing the limits and killing another 68030/040/060 that's NEVER gonna be replaced. NEVER! When you fry it, there's ONE less left in the world. PERIOD.

In my mind, EVERY Amigan got an obligation. To take the best care of his/her hardware as he/she can, and when he/she gets bored, SELL it to someone else who would LOVE to take care of it with love, tenderness and joy.

040's get rather hot.

A rule of thumb i use with ALL semiconductors, ESPECIALLY those that are irreplaceable, if you can't touch it, HEATSINK it! Better safe than sorry!

Someone mentioned they used fans and it sounded like an airplane...
SERIOUSLY?!? What fans did you use? Heard of Papst? Heard of using a size larger fan, running at a bit lower voltage? I got like 7 fans in my Define R3 PC case, and i can't hear them at all. The 9 3TB harddrives i got in it WASTLY overwhelms the silent fans.