Amiga.org

Amiga computer related discussion => Amiga Software Issues and Discussion => Topic started by: tonyvdb on December 04, 2014, 11:25:42 PM

Title: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: tonyvdb on December 04, 2014, 11:25:42 PM
So just got a new cd of OS 3.9 from Vesalia. Do I still also need to download the Boing bags and instal them or are they included in this CD? There is no info suplied with the CD saying anything about that.

Thanks
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: AmiKit on December 04, 2014, 11:29:10 PM
It's plain OS3.9. Download & Install the Boing Bags: http://os.amigaworld.de/index.php?lang=en&page=12
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: tonyvdb on December 04, 2014, 11:31:05 PM
Thank you :)
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: Oldsmobile_Mike on December 04, 2014, 11:43:38 PM
Also Boing Bags 3 & 4, here:

http://lilliput.amiga-projects.net/bbag4.htm

I'm running a fully patched 3.9 system with BB1-4 on my A2000, and even then I've found a few other things that were missed.  My suggestion is to just search the name of every program installed on Aminet (after doing the BB1-4 updates) to find any additional updates beyond what the Boing Bags install.   The Peter K. icon.library is an especially important one, since it really helps the performance of the computer and is updated about every month.  Have fun! :)
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: mechy on December 05, 2014, 03:53:15 AM
Quote from: Oldsmobile_Mike;779029
Also Boing Bags 3 & 4, here:

http://lilliput.amiga-projects.net/bbag4.htm

I'm running a fully patched 3.9 system with BB1-4 on my A2000, and even then I've found a few other things that were missed.  My suggestion is to just search the name of every program installed on Aminet (after doing the BB1-4 updates) to find any additional updates beyond what the Boing Bags install.   The Peter K. icon.library is an especially important one, since it really helps the performance of the computer and is updated about every month.  Have fun! :)

Watch out for these, there are some things in them that seem to cause scsi troubles and some odd problems, i never could pinpoint it,but going back to os3.9 install with just BB1&2 seemed to fix it. I would suggest making a os3.9 backup to some drawer on the HD with just BB1/2 to fall back on in case then installing 3&4 on the main partition.
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: Oldsmobile_Mike on December 05, 2014, 04:44:07 AM
Quote from: mechy;779047
Watch out for these, there are some things in them that seem to cause scsi troubles and some odd problems, i never could pinpoint it,but going back to os3.9 install with just BB1&2 seemed to fix it. I would suggest making a os3.9 backup to some drawer on the HD with just BB1/2 to fall back on in case then installing 3&4 on the main partition.

When I did mine I did a completely fresh install.  Made a 3.9 recovery floppy and booted off that, formatted my hard drive then threw in the OS 3.9 CD and installed it, then BB 1-4, one right after the other, all in a row.  Most of the times I've heard people having problems with 3-4 is when they install them on top of an already running system, with who knows what stuff already installed and configured.  But yeah, I should have included a disclaimer: "your mileage may vary".  ;)

My .02 cents, I think it's worth the risk if you want "the latest and greatest" 3.9 system you can have.  But it never hurts to make backups along the way.  ;)
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: Minuous on December 05, 2014, 09:23:05 AM
Quote from: Oldsmobile_Mike;779029
I've found a few other things that were missed.  My suggestion is to just search the name of every program installed on Aminet (after doing the BB1-4 updates) to find any additional updates beyond what the Boing Bags install.   The Peter K. icon.library is an especially important one, since it really helps the performance of the computer and is updated about every month.  Have fun! :)

Which things? BB4 icon.library is 46.4.397 which is the same version as on Aminet.

Quote from: mechy
Watch out for these, there are some things in them that seem to cause scsi troubles and some odd problems, i never could pinpoint it

If you believe there is a compatibility issue with your system, you can lodge a bug report.
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: guest11527 on December 05, 2014, 09:26:07 AM
Quote from: Minuous;779059
If you believe there is a compatibility issue with your system, you can lodge a bug report.

One of the things that seem to cause trouble here or there is the updated scsi.device (actually, IDE device) that came with one of the BBs. Unfortunately, Heinz doesn't seem to care anymore, so it's unfortunately pretty hard to update it.
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: Ancalimon on December 05, 2014, 09:26:39 AM
boingbag 3 and 4 are not magic. They really shouldn't cause any problem on a proper system. All they do is to fix the bugs of a few old rom modules installed by boingbag2 setpatch and add a few programs that were used by majority of OS3.9 users.
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: Oldsmobile_Mike on December 05, 2014, 11:49:19 AM
Quote from: Minuous;779059
Which things? BB4 icon.library is 46.4.397 which is the same version as on Aminet.

Things.  You're just going to have to trust me on this, it's been a year since I did it and I didn't exactly keep a list.  ;)

But that's exactly what I did.  I installed 3.9.  I installed BB1, 2, 3, 4.  Then I went on Aminet and typed in the name of every program in WBStartup, libraries, etc., and I found versions of things that were still newer.  ;)
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: tonyvdb on December 05, 2014, 01:51:00 PM
All good points to look out for, thanks!
I will be doing a fresh install on a blank SD card. Any tips on doing a fresh install from CD, Do I have to have a workbench disk handy in order for it to recognize the cd drive?

Im planning to do the install this weekend.
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: Oldsmobile_Mike on December 05, 2014, 02:13:22 PM
Quote from: tonyvdb;779068
All good points to look out for, thanks!
I will be doing a fresh install on a blank SD card. Any tips on doing a fresh install from CD, Do I have to have a workbench disk handy in order for it to recognize the cd drive?

On the 3.9 CD is a tool to make an emergency recovery floppy.  I booted off that and it didn't have any trouble recognizing my CD drive to complete the install (once I changed the HDToolbox tooltype from "scsi.device" to "gvpscsi.device").
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: mechy on December 05, 2014, 04:31:03 PM
Quote from: Minuous;779059
Which things? BB4 icon.library is 46.4.397 which is the same version as on Aminet.



If you believe there is a compatibility issue with your system, you can lodge a bug report.

thanks,I would ,but as i stated i never tracked down what the problem was exactly.I just left the fresh install with bb1&2 and called it a day.
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: SpeedGeek on December 05, 2014, 05:31:08 PM
FYI, BB3 & 4 are a reasonable attempt to fix the bugs left in BB1 & 2 so in most cases they should provide better reliability and stability.

There may be a few cases where BB3 & 4 may seem less stable than BB1 & 2 but they are probably hardware specific cases which could not be tested by the BB3 & 4 contributors. ;)
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: Minuous on December 05, 2014, 11:35:10 PM
Quote from: mechy;779077
thanks,I would ,but as i stated i never tracked down what the problem was exactly.I just left the fresh install with bb1&2 and called it a day.

Yes, rather than actually lodge a bug report, so that the issue could be properly investigated and fixed, you decided to just spread FUD about the package on public forums instead.
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: tonyvdb on December 05, 2014, 11:57:37 PM
Ok, so I have the ide cable hooked up to the 4way ide interface do I hook the cd rom into that cable or to the 4way adapter? I'm not getting the CD rom drive to recognize using the emergency boot disc.
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: Ancalimon on December 06, 2014, 12:33:45 AM
Quote from: tonyvdb;779097
Ok, so I have the ide cable hooked up to the 4way ide interface do I hook the cd rom into that cable or to the 4way adapter? I'm not getting the CD rom drive to recognize using the emergency boot disc.

If you plug the CD drive to 1st port as slave, I guess it would get detected.

I guess if you plug it to the second port, it would require an update to the scsi.device and a reboot to make the second port activated. (which should be inside the S:startup-sequence of the emergency boot floppy)

Of course you need to edit the cd0 (or cd1 or cd2 or cd3) inside DEVS: DosDrivers directory and change the device and unit according to where you connected the drive to.
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: tonyvdb on December 06, 2014, 01:36:56 AM
So if I keep the cd drive connected to port 2 one the 4way I need to chage it to master and select CD2?
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: LoadWB on December 06, 2014, 01:45:09 AM
Quote from: Minuous;779096
Yes, rather than actually lodge a bug report, so that the issue could be properly investigated and fixed, you decided to just spread FUD about the package on public forums instead.

I didn't ready anything FUDdy in his post.  Just carefully worded and reasonable warnings:

1) He had some problems after installing BB3 and BB4
2) He did not track down the problems, but rather corrected them by rolling back to BB2
3) Recommends having a backup before installing BB3 and BB4 -- BB1 and BB2 make this recommendation, as well.

No fear, uncertainty, or doubt there, IMNSHO: 1 is a statement of factual experience, 2 is an admission of not wanting to be bothered finding the problem, and 3 is good and solid advice before making any changes to a critical system.  When queried further, he just said "things" happened to him that he didn't want to bother with.  Another perfectly valid response when something goes wrong and you lack skill, time, or wherewithal to troubleshoot.  Nor is anyone obligated to do so, let alone make a report on the grounds that "something" is screwy.

It's happened to me in the past with other software packages, and no package nor collection of packages are immune to something going awry, given the massive variety of system configurations which exist in the wild.  Nothing here worth taking offense to.
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: Ancalimon on December 06, 2014, 01:53:48 AM
Quote from: tonyvdb;779105
So if I keep the cd drive connected to port 2 one the 4way I need to chage it to master and select CD2?


Yes. (Or you can still use CD0 but you'll have to edit it make it unit 2)

The important part is to have the appropriate lines in the Startup-Sequence that would enable the second port and reboot so that it becomes available.
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: Oldsmobile_Mike on December 06, 2014, 04:52:46 AM
Quote from: tonyvdb;779105
So if I keep the cd drive connected to port 2 one the 4way I need to chage it to master and select CD2?

This isn't one of those adapters that needs a software patch to activate port 2, is it?  For ease of setup it might be easier to keep the CD drive as slave on port 1 (with your hard drive as master) for the initial config.  Just something to check if you're still having issues!  ;)
Title: Re: OS 3.9 and Boing bags?
Post by: tonyvdb on December 06, 2014, 03:31:30 PM
Yup, it seems like it does need a software patch so its giving me grief. Im not getting anywhere.
I tried putting the CF card with OS3.1 that I got from AmigaKit directly on the IDE connector on the A40000 motherboard and it only just boots into the WB screen and freezes at that point (the capslock LED flashes on the keyboard)
Ideas?