Amiga.org
Amiga computer related discussion => Amiga Hardware Issues and discussion => Topic started by: Jose on February 11, 2004, 06:48:27 PM
-
Finally getting a network card for my A1200, but of networking I don't understand a sh*t! With all the options on network cards available and also some different devices available, each supporting different cards, I don't know what to choose so...
1- Which device is currently the best in terms of features, SPEED, stability, compatibility etc.. This affects the card I'll choose. I read cnet is cool.
2- Well, any particular card that is cool and you could recommend?. Some are easy to get on eBay.
3- If I remember correctly 10/100Mb/s cards won't work, or they'll work only on 10Mb/s?
4- What's the speed limit of the PCMCIA network cards that work on the A1200? I remember reading reports of about 64Mb/s wich is slow!! Is that a limitation on the Amiga side?
I searched some SCSI network adapters around and couldn't find any.. that would be faster...
5- Any other advice..?
THX
-
I have an A1200, Blizzard 1240/40 wich SCSI2 by way..
-
The cards will probably be able to connect to a 100 mbps-network, but the actual speed won't be more than 6-7 mbps at best IIRC.
-
Towered with Zorro?
-
@red
No. I have a spare A1200 mobo to do that though :-o, but I'm out of cash... :-( :-D
-
@whabang
6-7 mbps ?!! That's not that bad comparing to 64Mb/s !. But is that the effective data transmission or the connection speed?
-
Clarifying:
With a PCMCIA-NIC you might get a connection speed of 100mbps, but the actual transfers are unlikely to be faster than 6 or 7 mbps.
-
The speed for amiga-pc while copying a file through FTP is at most 800kb/s using Genesis and a FastEthernet-card.
With a 10Mbit-card you'll get 600kb/s using Genesis.
With MiamiDx the speed will be 300-400kb/s.
-
Hmm, somewhat different speeds you two mention....
Anyway, I got another question: Since the A1200's PCMCIA port can do around 3.5MB/s (or was that Mb/s??) with the Squirrel SCSI interface, would it be possible to use a 100Mb/s card even though getting less speed, but still faster than using 10Mb/s?
I'd still like some advice as to which card to choose, a NE2000 compatible or a 3Com Etherlink III compatibles...
-
Jose, where are you from?
-
Erm, hold on - on my A1200 (http://www.legolas.com/amiga/myamiga.html) , with a 10mbit/sec PCMCIA card, at best I get ~292KB/sec, regardless of what service/software is being used... latest cnet driver as well.
-
@x56h34
Portugal
-
Check out this e-bay auction:
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=3458515647 (http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=3458515647)
I just received 5 of those from UK to Canada. IMO, the best PCMCIA card to be used with A600/A1200 as it requires no dongle. Everythign is built in. Only 3GBP per piece.
-
Just bought one :-)
-
@x56h34
Well, the price is really great but I think I prefer a 10/100Mb one. Who knows maybe someone will be able writte a driver to get more speed with one, even if not fullspeed....
-
AFAIK it's not the card, it's the bus. The one in the A600/1200 is ancient, a Type 1 IIRC. Aka "slow and crap".
-
It's the CPU, 060 is highly recommended for good performance with PCMCIA NICs.
With 060 I could reach 786KB/s (the other end was just silly P120 laptop). A friend could reach 819KB/s. Both with 10mbit cards.
These are real-world ftp transfer speeds, not some imaginary theoretical values.
Unfortunately I no longer have the Amiga built up, so I can't test my 100mbit PCMCIA NIC in real 100mbit network. I wouldn't expect much over 1MB/s speed, however.