Amiga.org

Amiga computer related discussion => Amiga Hardware Issues and discussion => Topic started by: magnetic on November 19, 2010, 02:40:24 AM

Title: Amiga 1200 RF Shield.. Necessary???
Post by: magnetic on November 19, 2010, 02:40:24 AM
hey guys

I'm just wondering if you completely remove your A1200s rf shield will there be video noise on the composite out? What about the RGB port? tia
Title: Re: Amiga 1200 RF Shield.. Necessary???
Post by: save2600 on November 19, 2010, 02:50:58 AM
RGB - nope
Composite - probably not
RF out - probably a little

The FCC likes to see shields on this stuff so as to not cause interference across other peoples gear nearby. In practice though, I think it's all a bunch of rubbish that's not so neatly wrapped up and mired in politics.
Title: Re: Amiga 1200 RF Shield.. Necessary???
Post by: Iggy on November 19, 2010, 03:26:08 AM
Quote from: save2600;592975
RGB - nope
Composite - probably not
RF out - probably a little

The FCC likes to see shields on this stuff so as to not cause interference across other peoples gear nearby. In practice though, I think it's all a bunch of rubbish that's not so neatly wrapped up and mired in politics.


Seconded (except I'd say Composite - very unlikely).

The chance that significant RF interference would be created by this move is really small. And, by FCC standards, were you to create a problem with someone elses electronics you'd only be obligated to remedy the situation.

If there's an advantage in it for you, I'd go for it.
Title: Re: Amiga 1200 RF Shield.. Necessary???
Post by: TCMSLP on November 19, 2010, 10:11:32 AM
Quote from: save2600;592975
RGB - nope
Composite - probably not
RF out - probably a little

The FCC likes to see shields on this stuff so as to not cause interference across other peoples gear nearby. In practice though, I think it's all a bunch of rubbish that's not so neatly wrapped up and mired in politics.


I remember many years ago the shielding made a large difference in terms of reception of short wave on a nearby radio.  With shield = some interference, without shield = totally destroyed reception.

I also remember in my teenage years I had an Atari ST (boo hiss!) that I could 'pause' using my CB radio.  Key up the radio and the whole machine would halt - only to continue perfectly when I let go of the mic.   I always thought this was a pretty neat trick; but in hindsight I guess this is entirely possible if the clock gets neatly halted.

Shields are there for a reason though, even if you personally don't suffer with EMC issues.   In a mdoern house with wifi, bluetooth, mobile phones etc - perhaps there's more reason than ever to have shielding.   I wonder how many random miggy crashes are due to a mobile phone sitting nearby and lack of shielding?  Just curious :)


Steve
(operating with A1200 shield removed to create space for internal fans)