Amiga.org
Amiga computer related discussion => General chat about Amiga topics => Topic started by: don27dog on May 09, 2009, 10:26:37 AM
-
IMO the only way for Amiga to once again become a mainstream OS is to port OS4.x to x86 and create classic card with a 68xxx based processor that could run all classic software.
-
Download AROS, the Icaros distribuion is a good one... Be happy :-)
-
:lol:
:flame: "Be happy" = "Settle" here.
Amigans, innovators, and geniuses NEVER settle for less than the best--demand the best, and if they don't give it, stick another pin into their voodoo doll til they see the light. :roflmao:
-
IMO the only way for Amiga to once again become a mainstream OS is to port OS4.x to x86 and create classic card with a 68xxx based processor that could run all classic software.
Not worth it. You will need a complete rewrite to bring AOS up to modern standards. Add in the pricing of such a PCI-E card, your making the retail cost down right silly for 25 year old software. Only I can see that can remotely make some people happy is Anubis-OS and they need a heck of a lot more coders to get it up to speed.
-
from dammy:
Not worth it. You will need a complete rewrite to bring AOS up to modern standards. Add in the pricing of such a PCI-E card, your making the retail cost down right silly for 25 year old software. Only I can see that can remotely make some people happy is Anubis-OS and they need a heck of a lot more coders to get it up to speed.
Hi dammy, nice to see you. :-D
Anubis. Just what the community needed--yet another OS to split coder allegiances. I told you in email Anubis won't last (I still think that). What happened that it got created, when AROS is|was supposedly going so well?
I recall proposing a similar idea on moobunny about a classic (as in chip) based PCI card to run the old classic stuff in regular PeeCees. Of *course* the Amiga OS would have to be modernized--the backward compatibility was just a small (even possibly optional) feature idea. There were bigger plans, a much bigger vision in mind. :angel:
(the death of Microsoft Windows is still part of that, of course) 8-)
-
Yep, AROS is your new x86 Amiga! Problem solved :-)
-
AROS has never been, nor will it ever be, my new AMIGA OS. I don't like AROS, and certainly not any of the developers working on it (especially Matt Parsons)
-
EyeAm wrote:
AROS has never been, nor will it ever be, my new AMIGA OS. I don't like AROS, and certainly not any of the developers working on it (especially Matt Parsons)
WooHoo! :lol:
Remember me from ann.lu then ;-)
-
My old PC is more or less free now. It would make a fun AROS box, I suspect.
-
Karlos wrote:
My old PC is more or less free now. It would make a fun AROS box, I suspect.
Do it!!! I can't promise you more fun with a stinky old PC ;-)
-
bloodline wrote:
Karlos wrote:
My old PC is more or less free now. It would make a fun AROS box, I suspect.
Do it!!! I can't promise you more fun with a stinky old PC ;-)
It'll probably happen, unless the good lady wants to take the machine.
I suppose there's nothing stopping me running AROS in a VM on the new PC, right? Four cores, I'm sure one of them can be spared for the job.
-
Karlos wrote:
bloodline wrote:
Karlos wrote:
My old PC is more or less free now. It would make a fun AROS box, I suspect.
Do it!!! I can't promise you more fun with a stinky old PC ;-)
It'll probably happen, unless the good lady wants to take the machine.
I suppose there's nothing stopping me running AROS in a VM on the new PC, right? Four cores, I'm sure one of them can be spared for the job.
Go on!!! Give it half an hour, Nothing to lose... :-P
-
IMO the only way for Amiga to once again become a mainstream OS is to port OS4.x to x86 and create classic card with a 68xxx based processor that could run all classic software.
How would that make it a mainstream OS?
-
Golem!dk wrote:
IMO the only way for Amiga to once again become a mainstream OS is to port OS4.x to x86 and create classic card with a 68xxx based processor that could run all classic software.
How would that make it a mainstream OS?
Also, why would you need a card for backwards compatibility? It isn't as if modern x86/x64 hardware isn't more than capable of software emulating everything in a classic Amiga flawlessly.
-
Karlos wrote:
Golem!dk wrote:
IMO the only way for Amiga to once again become a mainstream OS is to port OS4.x to x86 and create classic card with a 68xxx based processor that could run all classic software.
How would that make it a mainstream OS?
Also, why would you need a card for backwards compatibility? It isn't as if modern x86/x64 hardware isn't more than capable of software emulating everything in a classic Amiga flawlessly.
Not to mention, the horrific sync problems of using a real board... best just do all the emulation in software. :-)
-
@Matt
So, what's the status of "transparent" 680x0 emulation in AROS these days then?
There's supposedly a HPUX server at work somewhere which allegedly runs legacy big endian binaries under some form of emulation under the newer x86 based OS. I'm not sure of the details though.
-
Karlos wrote:
@Matt
So, what's the status of "transparent" 680x0 emulation in AROS these days then?
Exciting:
http://o1i.blogspot.com/
:-D
(http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_ypaUlffYZrw/Seh9RY1PJhI/AAAAAAAAAEA/_7El9C_c9hg/s1600/j-ww-menu2.jpg) <- -Edit- Stoopid blogspot ;-)
-
don27dog wrote:
IMO the only way for Amiga to once again become a mainstream OS is to port OS4.x to x86 and create classic card with a 68xxx based processor that could run all classic software.
I think AROS would be fine and enough as long as those people start making efforts for support of decent notebooks which are most people's PCs nowadays.
-
Aros runs fine on a couple of notebooks (tested myself), the problem is every notebook has different network card and sound card, and we have very few drivers ATM.AROS is also lacking support for wireless LAN on notebooks.
Put your money in AROS bounties and we are getting closer each day. ;-)
-
don27dog wrote:
IMO the only way for Amiga to once again become a mainstream OS is to port OS4.x to x86 and create classic card with a 68xxx based processor that could run all classic software.
I don't think PC users are looking for another operating system these days, so it's not at all clear to me how porting OS4 over to that equipment is going to make it mainstream, especially if OS4 is not available for free (given the availability of Linux).
-
orb85750 wrote:
don27dog wrote:
IMO the only way for Amiga to once again become a mainstream OS is to port OS4.x to x86 and create classic card with a 68xxx based processor that could run all classic software.
I don't think PC users are looking for another operating system these days, so it's not at all clear to me how porting OS4 over to that equipment is going to make it mainstream, especially if OS4 is not available for free (given the availability of Linux).
I think what you said in just a few words is a critically important opinion, ought to be killing this very x86 crusade.
Peace!
-
I don't care anymore whether or not Amiga will become "main Stream" again. I am having fun with my Amigas right now! If it were to become mainstream, no mater who was involved, some big major corporation will try to suck any and all fun out of it, all in the pursuit of the All mighty Dollar. We will never have the Amiga "back" so why dwell on it. Just have fun and enjoy it NOW! in 5 or 10 years when the last piece of equipment dies, Then you can mourn over it.
Even when so called "Amiga enthusiasts own the Amiga name, they screw it up in favor of making a buck or 2 on modern platforms. No owner will ever cater to the classic users.
Face it, the only future is what people like "Jens" are doing. Any hope for a new "AMIGA" OS is a joke, because it will never run on an Classic Amiga. They won't even be developed on an Classic Amiga. It will be Amiga in name only.
-
AmigaOS and its hardwares have already contributed so much in the whole computer industry and consumers. I admit that I did not grow during "the Amiga era" but there are streams of young people who are interested in Amiga because we see a very bleak impression on [cough, cough] M*cr*s*ft and willing to look into alternatives.
Anyway, I think Amiga will still survive in some forms or another. Perhaps the open source software and hardware movement will maintain Classical Amiga's legacy. Maybe some other company will make an operating system that has very much similarity with Classic Amiga with updated standards. I don't know but as long as we respect Amiga we will preserve Amiga.
-
AROS has never been, nor will it ever be, my new AMIGA OS. I don't like AROS, and certainly not any of the developers working on it (especially Matt Parsons)
well, although I have nothing at all to do with AROS
at least you can contact their developers and they will reply to your emails AND you can have a go yourself. I emailed Fabio once about AROS RAM: and he replied promptly, and I emailed Georg Steger about AROS par: around 2004. In response he wrote a utility which created some of the functionality of par:
Now I emailed the Friedens a number of times and NEVER received a reply.
When Commodore Amiga went bankrupt I tried to contact them about some idea and it was impossible to reach the decision makers.
They had a guy who told the developer audience at an Amiga show that if anyone had any ideas please contact him. I contacted him at the end of the meeting and he had no interest at all in hearing what I had to say despite saying he wanted to hear ideas!
and they had a whole group of apparatchiks running the company who had no interest in the company.
also I have Matt Parsons to thank for directing me to x86 and away from PPC.
Matt made it quite clear that x86 was the only option to consider.
I think you are a bit harsh about Matt, I am not aware of any bad behaviour by him.
I have never had any problems with the AROS developers but there are some characters on their developer mailing list who are troublemakers. Arguing and flaming incessantly and contributing nothing at all.
unfortunately ALL the Amiga projects including amiga.org attract some bad people who spend their entire time harrassing anyone trying to move the system forwards.
My own OS project has been greatly influenced by AROS. Their project is very pragmatic. And they have extended the Amiga paradigm to new hardware.
AROS is the only project definition which has a long term future for AmigaOS,
there is nothing to stop you starting your own branch of AROS.
Also AROS is hardware agnostic, the main work is x86 but there is also PPC AROS.
In fact I think people were looking at creating 68k AROS as a way to develop an opensource pseudo ROM for UAE.
its quite a major achievement to create a fully portable reimplementation of AmigaOS.
I think the ONLY future for AmigaOS is an open source unofficial reimplementation,
and that is what AROS is.
the official closed source path is doomed because its an inescapable legal web.
someone is sitting on the rights and will prevent any attempt at x86 AmigaOS.
but they are powerless to stop AROS, which means its a way through for the platform.
With Unix, the future of Unix is Linux. Linux is an open source reimplementation of Unix.
I was looking at installing todays version of the original version of Unix, until I found that they used Linux drivers for their graphics!
At that point I realised that Linux IS the future of Unix
-
IMO the only way for Amiga to once again become a mainstream OS is to port OS4.x to x86 and create classic card with a 68xxx based processor that could run all classic software.
Do you really mean Mainstream (i.e. millions)? or do you mean used by more than a few thousand, but still less than, say, tens of thousands or perhaps 100,000 at the upper limit?