Amiga.org

Amiga News and Community Announcements => Amiga News and Community Announcements => Amiga.org site announcements => Topic started by: Kees on August 31, 2003, 05:07:06 PM

Title: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: Kees on August 31, 2003, 05:07:06 PM
For the next interview, we have lined up none other then Dave Haynie.    :-D

So if you have a question for Dave, feel free to submitt it in this thread.
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: Floid on August 31, 2003, 05:19:09 PM
Didja get any onya?
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: KennyR on August 31, 2003, 05:23:00 PM
This will probably start a flame war if it's asked, but it's something we all need to know:

· Do you still feel the same way about MorphOS?

and

· How do you feel about other projects like Amithlon/Umilator and AROS, if you've heard of them?
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: Lando on August 31, 2003, 05:50:23 PM
What do you think about the recent announcements from Merlancia, regarding their new Amigas based on the old MCC designs?
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: bloodline on August 31, 2003, 05:55:18 PM
When did you first become aware/get involved with the Amiga project and what were your first thoughts about it?

What were your favourite aspects of the Amiga hardware (OCS, ECS and AGA... other?)?

What were your favourite aspects of the Amiga operating system (1.x, 2.x and 3.x)?

What was the earilest point you realised that games were going to go heavily into 3D and that the Amiga's chipset was not going to be right for it (basicly when did you want to start work on a chipset geared up for 3D work?)?

Which do you like best AOS4, MorphOS or AROS... ok that was a joke... no seriously... alright I can't ask that one... maybe I can... I'll let Dave decide :-)


-Edit- Oh and cheers for Disksalv2 , since It saved my GCSE cource work :-)
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: Hisham on August 31, 2003, 06:14:47 PM
1. I know you were not involved in management, but perhaps you can shed some light on whether the coup d’estat by Gould & Co. in the early eighties causing Tramiel to move elsewhere was the beginning of C='s downfall and loosing touch with the market?

2. Do you think the desktop/tower computer system market is over and that whatever new thing the next Amiga will be, it shouldn't be a desktop (ala notions of the A1000 in '84), but perhaps something else like a portable "media machine" which brings on a whole new paradigm in computing for the next twenty years (just like the altair did for desktops)?

3. Who would make up your dream hardware/software engineering team for creating a new Amiga?

4. Who would manage the team and market their wizardry?

5. What is your opinion on Linux, technically.

6. What is your opinion on Linux, as a replacement for mainstream OS's (Windows, MacOS)?

Thanks Haynie!  :-D

-------------------------
Hisham Khalifa
AmigaDiraz, Bahrain
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: lempkee on August 31, 2003, 06:15:19 PM
bloodline: buy the deathbed vigil dvd, then u will a answer to 99% of all your questions.


dave: The merlancia hoax'ters are at it again,
should we belive in em this time or? , i know
you allready answered to this in april/may 2003,
but now we have seen the specs etc , but it doesnt say what OS so i feel its still a hoax.


cheers
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: bloodline on August 31, 2003, 06:23:33 PM
Quote

lempkee wrote:
bloodline: buy the deathbed vigil dvd, then u will a answer to 99% of all your questions.
cheers


Well I'm waiting for the PAL DVD!!!!!

Wich is actually a good question, when will the PAL DVD be ready?
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: chris on August 31, 2003, 07:06:30 PM
What, in your opinion, is technically the best graphics card currently available?

What do you see as limitations of current graphics chipsets over AGA (and AAA, Hombre etc) - do Amiga chipsets still have any advantages in this field?

And finally, if you had to engineer a new Amiga today, what would it be like?

Chris
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: alx on August 31, 2003, 07:18:08 PM
Had Commodore survived, do you think that the Amiga would have stayed as custom as it was, or would it have become more like the A1/Pegasos?

Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: Roj on August 31, 2003, 08:25:07 PM
What advantages, if any, do you see still remaining in AmigaOS over other platforms today?

Do you still see the Amiga in its many incarnations as a viable computing option?
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: xisp on August 31, 2003, 09:00:44 PM
1)
Please, Give us your own definition of what is an Amiga.
2)
Which company or organization do you think is acting more wisely in todays IT industry?
(wisely means they innovate and make money at
the same time without fu*king people up)
3)
Where have all the flowers gone? ;-)

Thank you even if my questions aren't finally answered.
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: dammy on August 31, 2003, 09:45:50 PM
What is your new company about and when can we find out  more about it's product line?

Dammy
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: GadgetMaster on August 31, 2003, 10:13:27 PM
You are generally well respected in the Amiga community. Do you still enjoy the attention or is the Amiga something you would like to leave as part of your past?

Do you still keep tabs on progress in this small and strange market?
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: carls on August 31, 2003, 10:42:11 PM
1) What do you think of today's consumer graphics hardware, IE the stuff from nVidia and ATI? Would AAA in any way be comparable in 2D performance?
2) Was AAA chunky or planar?
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: peroxidechicken on August 31, 2003, 10:52:40 PM
What companies did Gould and Ali destroy next?  Where are they now?  
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: downix on September 01, 2003, 01:26:11 AM
Alright, get a chance to ask this:

Some of us got into a discussion about weither or not you designed any of the custom chips yourself or not.  So the question is simple, did you have any involvement in the creation of the custom chips, weither they were AGA, AAA or one of the control ASIC's like Budgie or Buster?
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: DonnyEMU on September 01, 2003, 02:59:57 AM
What do you think GPUs of today are missing ? Have you been keeping up with Nvidia's NV30's and above.

Most graphic cards today have a vector processor for doing matrix math, but they have a limited number of instructions available if you are programming real time pixel and vertex shader technology for them in shader languages (ASM shaders, CGshaders, etc.). how do you see barriers in bandwidth, instruction sets, etc.  being overcome?

In just about two years 200dpi lcd displays will be readily available on the market and one would expect that operatings systems might more tightly integrate 3d into their UI and maybe even directly support 3d capable cards and support these higher definition displays ..

What would you do if you were producing hardware to fit into this brave new world what would you do to improve the user experience..

Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: Acill on September 01, 2003, 04:16:42 AM
I*'d love to know what happened to Ali and Gould. I cant find much info on the loosers.

Also Dave, What is your favorite Amiga of all time? I am a huge fan of tha A3000 and still have mine. I just about got a fully working A3000+ at Software Hut, but the price was just to much to take it.

How to you feel about the A4000 in relation to the A3000. It's allways felt like a rushed system to me, and is why I never got one. AGA didnt do much for me which was another reason not to get that A3000+

Do you have any tips for us A3000 users out here?

Thanks Dave!
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: Hooligan_DCS on September 01, 2003, 04:39:36 AM
You worked for Commodore back then and we all know what happened. Looking at things now, in 2003, several years after, do you think Amiga Inc. is doing a good job when it comes to present and future of Amiga/AmigaOS?

Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: tormedhammaren on September 01, 2003, 05:22:48 AM
How do you think the Amiga hardware would look today if Commodore hadn't went bankrupt? How would the Amiga graphics system look? Would it be non standard and based on AGA/AAA or would it be more like SVGA? What about the bus system? And, last but least, what processor architechure could the Amiga have been using?

How well did you like the AmigaOS and how well do you like it now?


Thank you
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: Floid on September 01, 2003, 06:25:46 AM
Okay, a little more seriously...

Name three products that, by all rights, should exist today but don't.  'Hardware,' A/V, communications, flying cars, whatever -- as someone who's been in the 'industry' for so long, what do you find most egregious about its present state?
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: shIva on September 01, 2003, 09:47:06 AM
some more from me - hope they are not too old or already answered :

- how are you ?
- what are your future plans ?
- where can i get the dvd you did ?
- which hardware do you prefer today ?
- what happened to the hardware you designed, that never was put into production ?
- do you think systems like a1/peggy have a chance ?
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: Jose on September 02, 2003, 03:19:27 PM
Ok since this interview is with Dave...

- Do you still use Amigas?:)

- True multitasking, almost instant booting times, real computing fun for the users that want to take computing to a further level (just look at a M$ book and I'll want to through up...), no need to "shut down", amazing responsiveness, just to mention some of the stuff that Windows  still doesn't have. Do you think there could still be some similar innovation at the hardware level, like the custom chips did at their time, or the maket is completely saturated?

- Do you think the Amiga has a future with this, or those "special "features in the AOS will just be finally "imitated" if people start to notice them...?

- Who owns the rights to AAA? (I know it's dated:))

- Probably just for the fun of it,  how much far from completion was the AAA chipset, and could it be implemented with toadays electronics, probably with some modifications... Would that reequire a big budget?

Cheers  
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: Kees on September 04, 2003, 01:15:38 AM
In 24 hour this thread will be closed, so if you still want to ask a question .. submit it now   :-D
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: weirdami on September 04, 2003, 02:24:12 AM
Do you have a dream OS in mind that would blow everything away, or is OS (and computers, for that matter) design pretty much where it's going to be for a long time coming? Are there features that you'd like to see that are in no computers right now, but should be, given that they would create a paradigm shift in the computing world for the better?


Forgive the Video Toaster reference. :-)
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: DonnyEMU on September 04, 2003, 06:19:46 AM
Reading thru the Dave Haynie archives online and especially the "hombre" documents, it's clear that Commodore saw AAA as the last of the Amigas and "Hombre" was a completely new computer and wouldn't have been even called an Amiga. It sounds like an ultra cool HP workstation that would have competed well with Sun boxes of the time.

Did Commodore see "Hombre" as a new generation machine and NOT an Amiga (can't see that it was in anyway compatible) or even an answer to the power mac..

-Don
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: Kees on September 04, 2003, 12:22:43 PM
10 hours left ...
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: redrumloa on September 04, 2003, 01:02:07 PM
Dave: Do you have anymore prototype or rare Amiga items in your basement?
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: Billsey on September 04, 2003, 04:26:53 PM
You've been through a lot of rough times, Dave. All I want to know is how are you holding up; and is there anything that you would like people to pray about in interceding for you?
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: redrumloa on September 04, 2003, 04:40:17 PM
Do you own the rights to the AmiJoe project. If so how much $$ would it take to fund the R&D to finish the project?
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: DeQuevedo on September 04, 2003, 06:08:24 PM
Hi!

My question is very simple, and very interesting:

"What means AMiGA for you?"
I mean Whats do you think is the real spirit of the AMiGA

Best Regards
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: x56h34 on September 04, 2003, 07:57:12 PM
Did Commodore ever plan to do something about making an accelerator board for A4000 which would host an 68060 CPU, and possibly extra RAM, etc. (kind of what we see today in the Cyberstorm line)?

Which cool upgrades were planned for A1200 and A4000 which never saw the light of day?

How close were we to seeing the J213's jumper feature "8MB ChipRAM" utilized, on A4000 motherboard?

For future Amiga developments, was Commodore considering PCI instead of Zorro III (or the next Zorro) by any chance?
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: Floid on September 05, 2003, 12:16:42 PM
Okay, sliding this in under the wire...

Slashdot has just featured one man's 'post-mortem' (if a bit late for a 'deathbed vigil') for Atari's headquarters.  
http://games.slashdot.org/games/03/09/05/0644214.shtml?tid=127&tid=186&tid=202 (http://games.slashdot.org/games/03/09/05/0644214.shtml?tid=127&tid=186&tid=202)

Any parting thoughts, while we have you on the stage?
Title: Re: Dave Haynie Interview - submit your questions
Post by: Kees on September 05, 2003, 06:04:51 PM
Thank you for submitting your questions for Dave Haynie.

We will make a selection of questions that we will send to Dave.

Stay tuned for his answers  :-)