Amiga.org

Amiga computer related discussion => Amiga Hardware Issues and discussion => Topic started by: wolfchild on May 29, 2008, 12:17:46 PM

Title: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: wolfchild on May 29, 2008, 12:17:46 PM
Around 8 months ago, as soon as Minimig PCBs were made available on Ebay, I made a big order from Digikey and bought the parts to assemble my own.

It took all of a week's lunch-breaks to assemble the unit's SMD parts, except for one thing - the FPGA.  In a fit of 'I know better' stupidity I ordered the wrong FPGA, and the project has been shelved for the last 8 months.

Does anyone know of a supplier for one-off XC3S400E-PQ208 FPGA's and without M.O.Q. restrictions?  Preferably in Europe as I don't want to pay some EUR30 in import taxes again.

I also have similar problems with the SD-card socket.  Farnell have an M.O.Q. policy that makes buying the socked a ridiculously expensive affair.

Thanks in advance!
Edwin
Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: skurk on May 29, 2008, 12:55:29 PM
I have all the parts except the FPGA myself.  It's about 80% done, laying in the drawer at work.

The SD card socket was indeed tricky to obtain.  I finally got one from another DIY electronics kit (ebay link (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/9-Db-Side-prototype-MCU-Develop-Board-PCB-Connectors_W0QQitemZ350064266221QQihZ022QQcategoryZ36327QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem)).  This kit also contains a couple of other parts (pushbuttons, serial port, etc) which come in handy.

I'm interested in building more than just one Minimig, so if you come across any good offers, let me know.
Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: wolfchild on May 29, 2008, 05:13:43 PM
Thanks for the info!  We seem to be exactly in the same situation with project progress...

I looked closely at the SD card socket supplied with the kit, but in the photo is looks different from what Dennis used for Minimig.  The original part for the Minimig has the solder connections hidden somewhere in the middle of the socket, whereas the one from your link has the connections at the back.  Did it fit OK for you?

Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: Hojo Norem on May 29, 2008, 06:35:05 PM
I'm building a Minimig too (Im waiting for IC8 on back order from DIgiKey and D2-D6 because they sent the wrong parts).  I got my SD card connector from CPC (http://www.cpc.co.uk) here in the UK.  They got a few different types in, even those spring loaded ones.

EDIT:
Their site is like a maze when you want to find anything so heres a search link: Might not work for long (http://cpc.farnell.com/jsp/search/browse.jsp?N=411+500001+1002243&Ntk=gensearch_003&Ntt=sd+card&Ntx=)
Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: DBAlex on May 29, 2008, 06:39:59 PM
Why build a minimig when you can buy one from AmigaKit & other places?

Is it cheaper, or is it just for fun?  :-?
Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: Hojo Norem on May 29, 2008, 06:51:39 PM
In the long run it works out a little more cost wise but you can spread that cost over a longer period as you buy the parts.  There is a fun aspect to it also but the biggest reason for me is that I had bought a PCB of eBay before Christmas.  Plus building it yourself opens up more customisation options when it comes to the finishing touches ;-)
Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: wolfchild on May 29, 2008, 07:08:53 PM
Quote
Why build a minimig when you can buy one from AmigaKit & other places?

Because if I had bought the right FPGA, I would have been amongst the very first to have a completed minimig!

Quote
Is it cheaper, or is it just for fun?

Cheaper it surely is not!  I've already paid too much import taxes and shipping and processing fees, but it's kind of cool having a 100% DIY Amiga :-)
Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: Everblue on May 29, 2008, 08:26:49 PM
Wolfchild: Jekk tlestih nista naqbeż qabża s'għandek ħa nara dan il-minimig jaħdem?



(If you finish it can I pay you a visit to see the minimig working?)
Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: amazing on May 29, 2008, 08:42:47 PM
buying the sd sockets from farnell was easy as peeing behind a tree

i will look for the number tonight so u can order it
Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: HenryCase on May 29, 2008, 09:13:53 PM
I don't know if they sell individual chips, but this place is worth a look:
http://www.ashlea.co.uk/scripts/availability.pl?partID=XC3S400-4PQG208C

The last time I enquired about Xilinx XC3S400-4PQG208C FPGAs I was asking for the bulk price, which for 20-100 chips was £13.40 GBP each. I didn't ask for the price for single chips.

Even if they do sell individual chips, it looks like you've got enough interested parties, i.e. people who have posted here, for at least 5 FPGAs. Something to think about.

If you would like to e-mail Ashlea Components their e-mail address is: sales@ashlea.co.uk .
Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: skurk on May 29, 2008, 10:25:25 PM
Quote

DBAlex wrote:
Why build a minimig when you can buy one from AmigaKit & other places?

Is it cheaper, or is it just for fun?  :-?


It's definitely not cheaper, but it's very educational.  I wish every hardware component was available as a DIY package.
Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: skurk on May 29, 2008, 10:28:28 PM
Quote

wolfchild wrote:
I looked closely at the SD card socket supplied with the kit, but in the photo is looks different from what Dennis used for Minimig.  The original part for the Minimig has the solder connections hidden somewhere in the middle of the socket, whereas the one from your link has the connections at the back.  Did it fit OK for you?


Actually - I haven't soldered it yet.  The connectors are at home, and the Minimig's at work.  Since I'm lacking the FPGA, it's all been "on hold" lately... so I haven't really thought much about it.

I'll take a look at it this weekend and double-check.
Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: skurk on May 29, 2008, 10:35:21 PM
Quote

HenryCase wrote:
The last time I enquired about Xilinx XC3S400-4PQG208C FPGAs I was asking for the bulk price, which for 20-100 chips was £13.40 GBP each. I didn't ask for the price for single chips.


That's a really great price.  Maybe someone in the UK are willing to stock up?  I'd love to, but I'm in Norway and we have a +25% tax on imports worth more than £20.

If someone in the UK did, they could send the FPGA's abroad as "gifts" :)

Hey, I'll have two.  Maybe three.
Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: HenryCase on May 30, 2008, 12:26:24 AM
Quote
skurk wrote:
I'd love to, but I'm in Norway and we have a +25% tax on imports worth more than £20.


There's a solution to the import tax issue: get the person sending the parcel to say the goods are worth less than £20! :-D I know someone who bought something on eBay recently and successfully used this trick.

Quote
skurk wrote:
If someone in the UK did, they could send the FPGA's abroad as "gifts" :)


That'd work too. :-D
Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: alexh on May 30, 2008, 12:45:10 AM
See if you can blag some from your local distributor as samples... with a bit of fast talking you can easily get 1-2 chips
Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: amigadave on May 30, 2008, 03:16:32 AM
Quote

DBAlex wrote:
Why build a minimig when you can buy one from AmigaKit & other places?

Is it cheaper, or is it just for fun?  :-?


I think I got the parts for about the same price as the A-Cube MiniMigs that are being sold, and I would have gone that route except I bought the board and started buying parts before A-Cube announced that they would be making them.

If anyone wants to buy all the parts to build one from me so I can buy a working one, I will gladly give up on making one.

I haven't started soldering yet, so the parts are all pristine, any offers?   :lol:

Edit: Don't bother offering to buy one or two of the parts, it is all or nothing and if the offer is not for an amount that will get me a completed Minimig, or very close, don't bother either as I am not interested in taking a huge loss on these parts that I have just recently received.  But if you really want to have a MiniMig that YOU put together yourself, then I have everything you need.
Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: wolfchild on June 06, 2008, 07:00:33 PM
Oh well, all attempts to get an FPGA from other sources proved to be complicated and led to nowhere.  I've given up the hunt and ordered almost everything from Digikey.

Now I have to source the Minimig's peculiar SD card connector.  Luckily I just found that Farnell has a local distributor here.  Well worth giving them a try...

Mmm, now I just need to buy me a new soldering iron, some lead-free solder and get it all done and assembled :-D
Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: skurk on June 09, 2008, 07:52:38 AM
Quote

skurk wrote:
Quote

wolfchild wrote:
I looked closely at the SD card socket supplied with the kit, but in the photo is looks different from what Dennis used for Minimig.  The original part for the Minimig has the solder connections hidden somewhere in the middle of the socket, whereas the one from your link has the connections at the back.  Did it fit OK for you?


Actually - I haven't soldered it yet.  The connectors are at home, and the Minimig's at work.  Since I'm lacking the FPGA, it's all been "on hold" lately... so I haven't really thought much about it.

I'll take a look at it this weekend and double-check.


..and, as it turns out, it didn't fit.  But it did provide me with the pushbuttons, power connector and joystick port.  And a helluva experimenter board to play with later.
Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: weirdami on June 09, 2008, 08:16:06 AM
Quote
Jekk tlestih nista naqbeż qabża s'għandek ħa nara dan il-minimig jaħdem?


Is that Maltish?
Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: alexh on June 09, 2008, 08:24:40 AM
Quote

Is that Maltish?

Maltese even.
Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: wolfchild on June 09, 2008, 10:56:19 AM
@skurk
Quote
..and, as it turns out, it didn't fit. But it did provide me with the pushbuttons, power connector and joystick port. And a helluva experimenter board to play with later


I thought so...  the particular SD card connector used in the Minimig seems to have no compatible alternative.  The kit is nice though.  I'd been eyeing something like it for quite some time as a tinkering toy.

@weirdami
Quote
Is that Maltish?


It is, as alexh pointed out, Maltese.  There's only two of us on this board who can communicate in it, apparently.
 
It's a pity, because at its peak, Amigas used to sell like hotcakes in Malta for Chrismas season, and the majority of my schoolmates had an Amiga at home.  I reckon that most never used the Amiga for anything but games... and have now moved on.
Title: Re: One off source for Minimig FPGA
Post by: Everblue on June 09, 2008, 11:06:12 AM
I quote that :)

I stuck to the Amiga 1200 back then since I think 1992 when things started to turn really bad. I have returned around 2000 for nostalgic reasons...

I did use Amiga mainly for games back then just like wolfchild explained, but if it wasn't for Deluxe Paint I wouldn't be doing what I do to earn a living today.