Amiga.org

Amiga computer related discussion => Amiga Software Issues and Discussion => Topic started by: nyteschayde on February 08, 2006, 09:21:41 PM

Title: OS4 Release Questions...
Post by: nyteschayde on February 08, 2006, 09:21:41 PM
I don't really understand the argument that OS4 needs to wait until new PPC hardware is released. I understand that ideally the OS will run best on new hardware but from what I understand it runs great on the thousands of PPC enabled classic machines. It *was* designed to support the classic machines so what's the deal?

It has to be corporate red tape. So my question is, how do we fix it? We should be able to appeal to the company holding back whether its Hyperion or AInc or whomever. How do we get them to understand that money coming in for classic machines and people who just want to stock up or support the OS can *only* help?!


And for god's sake, everybody has access to some old mac hardware. Add support for them and you have an enourmous base. Makes no freaking sense....


Ahem... sorry for that . :)
Title: Re: OS4 Release Questions...
Post by: justthatgood on February 08, 2006, 09:24:16 PM
Take over the offices Amiga Inc.  Not that they would really be doing anything over there.  Threaten a few people here there everywhere. :ak47:

Yeah, these are the clowns that are causing it.
Title: Re: OS4 Release Questions...
Post by: djbase on February 08, 2006, 09:36:15 PM
Quote
I understand that ideally the OS will run best on new hardware but from what I understand it runs great on the thousands of PPC enabled classic machines.


There are less than 1.000 PowerUP User left.

Title: Re: OS4 Release Questions...
Post by: Karlos on February 08, 2006, 09:37:11 PM
Quote

nyteschayde wrote:

It has to be corporate red tape.


I think red & white chequered tape perchance :lol:
Title: Re: OS4 Release Questions...
Post by: nyteschayde on February 08, 2006, 09:44:33 PM
@DJBase

Is that number based on those who answered the poll at amiga.org who happened to be on when the poll was up or are there nice little actively powered RFID tags on each BPPC/CSPPC that inform the world of the remaining quantity?

Not to be too much of a smartass but seriously are those numbers a guess or based on fact somehow. For exmaple I have a BPPC that I am waiting to use. So that will be one more that's in use and I didn't answer the poll cause I didn't have one at the time.
Title: Re: OS4 Release Questions...
Post by: The_Editor on February 08, 2006, 09:46:22 PM

:lol:

Offices at Amiga Inc ?


Bwahahahahahahaahahaaaaaaaaaa



/me pisses self laughing !!
Title: Re: OS4 Release Questions...
Post by: KThunder on February 08, 2006, 09:51:23 PM
ha ha umm

/me steps back to avoid said piss

one word [color=ff0000]AROS[/color][/b][/i]

leave the vapor, it smells better out here
Title: Re: OS4 Release Questions...
Post by: nyteschayde on February 08, 2006, 09:59:55 PM
Re: AROS

...and I thought there wasn't enough software for the Amiga, look at this clean little empty closet.
Title: Re: OS4 Release Questions...
Post by: djbase on February 08, 2006, 10:50:24 PM
Quote
Not to be too much of a smartass but seriously are those numbers a guess or based on fact somehow.


There is a PowerUP registration running since Dec 2005 and the numbers are far away from 1000 so dont expect more.

Title: Re: OS4 Release Questions...
Post by: Matt_H on February 08, 2006, 11:00:52 PM
Just because only 1000 people answered doesn't mean there's only 1000 boards/users left. My father has 2 boards that he hasn't registered. There have to be other users out there who haven't heard of the survey or just aren't filling it out. Plus it's only been going 2 months. If you want accurate survey data, that's not enough time, especially for one that users need to discover on their own.
Title: Re: OS4 Release Questions...
Post by: djbase on February 08, 2006, 11:12:09 PM
Quote
Just because only 1000 people answered doesn't mean there's only 1000 boards/users left. My father has 2 boards that he hasn't registered. There have to be other users out there who haven't heard of the survey or just aren't filling it out. Plus it's only been going 2 months. If you want accurate survey data, that's not enough time, especially for one that users need to discover on their own.


And? Do you think even if 1000 users were left that all will buy OS4? Will your dad buy 2 copies because he has 2 cards? He was also talking of thousands. If there are thousands of users left were have they all gone? Why does the software sell doing that bad? Well, we will see if there are much more users outthere in 4 months. I doubt that. The amiga market is very tiny these days.

Title: Re: OS4 Release Questions...
Post by: amiwalker on February 09, 2006, 01:40:07 AM
Just get the NEW hardware out there and they will come!!

We NEED the Hardware NOW!!

PLEASE!

I will buy it and OS4

I also fear IB2.4 will not be released until OS4 and new hardware are.

ARRRRRRRRGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG!

Title: Re: OS4 Release Questions...
Post by: bloodline on February 09, 2006, 03:53:35 PM
Quote

DJBase wrote:
Quote
Not to be too much of a smartass but seriously are those numbers a guess or based on fact somehow.


There is a PowerUP registration running since Dec 2005 and the numbers are far away from 1000 so dont expect more.



I've not registered yet, as I've no had time to pop the bottom off my miggy and look at the S/N  :-(
Title: Re: OS4 Release Questions...
Post by: djbase on February 09, 2006, 04:33:56 PM
Quote
I've not registered yet, as I've no had time to pop the bottom off my miggy and look at the S/N


You can at last get the serial of the BPPC/CSPPC with Scout or WhichAmiga output.
Title: Re: OS4 Release Questions...
Post by: SamuraiCrow on February 09, 2006, 06:17:37 PM
Quote

nyteschayde wrote:
I don't really understand the argument that OS4 needs to wait until new PPC hardware is released. I understand that ideally the OS will run best on new hardware but from what I understand it runs great on the thousands of PPC enabled classic machines. It *was* designed to support the classic machines so what's the deal?

It has to be corporate red tape. So my question is, how do we fix it? We should be able to appeal to the company holding back whether its Hyperion or AInc or whomever. How do we get them to understand that money coming in for classic machines and people who just want to stock up or support the OS can *only* help?!


The idea is to have a big rollout when AmigaOS 4 is finally released.  There will be advertizing and everything.  It wouldn't make sense to advertise a system that cannot sell to new users because of no new hardware would it?

As for the Mac, they use custom chipsets made explicitly by Apple for the Macintosh.  To build an OS to support it you'd need reference materials and permission from Apple to do it.  Reverse engineering works for open-source freeware operating systems like AROS because there is no money behind the designers and essentially nobody for Apple to sue.

Who wants to be stuck for the rest of their lives trying to find old machines that may fail at any minute when they can have a brand new machine instead.  I for one am thankful that there are new boards coming out other than the AmigaOne line since that means we may have some reliable machines at last.
Title: Re: OS4 Release Questions...
Post by: nyteschayde on February 10, 2006, 08:08:10 AM
@DJBase

Do you honestly think the number of new Amiga hardware owners are greater than the number of classic PPC owners? I find it a little hard to believe.

@SamuraiCrow

C'mon man. Many many distributions of Linux exist including Darwin which is released by Apple all boot and run and have hardware acceleration, etc... for existing Mac machines. There is no lack of documentation on doing what would be required. Furthermore I would be very surprised if they don't have a working version of it for mac hardware, the only thing that would need to be dropped (assuming they do) is the requirement for the amiga TPM hardware built in to the A1s/A1 compatibles.
Title: Re: OS4 Release Questions...
Post by: itix on February 10, 2006, 09:13:03 AM
@SamuraiCrow

Quote

The idea is to have a big rollout when AmigaOS 4 is finally released. There will be advertizing and everything.


It indeed would be futile have TV commercials on MTV now when hardware is not available.
Title: Re: OS4 Release Questions...
Post by: xeron on February 10, 2006, 09:20:59 AM
Quote

You can at last get the serial of the BPPC/CSPPC with Scout or WhichAmiga output.


Oh cool. The one thing that had stopped me registering so far was that i'd have to open my A4000 to get at the serial number!
Title: Re: OS4 Release Questions...
Post by: CHR_ZD on February 10, 2006, 10:11:45 AM
Soemthing for sure... if os4 will ever be released it will be a big laughingstock. Why? Because PPC is dead. An OS that can't run on x86 is a deadstock already. Amiga wasn't meant to be some obscure geek thing. It was a computer for the masses. Their policy is to destroy it forever.
Title: Re: OS4 Release Questions...
Post by: nyteschayde on February 10, 2006, 05:42:55 PM
@CHR_ZD

On one hand I'd like to see linux or even MacOS on either the PS3 or the XBOX360 since both have a high chance of being compatible and since both platforms will be the greatest perpetuator of the PPC platform for mass consumers at the moment.

On the other hand, I'd be extremely worried that OS4 wouldn't be taken seriously at all on either of these consoles unless other major OSes were ported first. It's a shame both of those consoles have more processing power than many home machines and at a fraction of the cost.

@all

I really think the OS should come out sooner than later. They can make up the cost of development on classic users and deploy the OS in an advertised and possibly even patched and more functional version on the new hardware when it becomes available. I have heard from multiple sources that the OS is basically ready for a release and would have been released were it not for the lack of hardware.