Amiga.org

Coffee House => Coffee House Boards => CH / General => Topic started by: that_punk_guy on July 14, 2004, 11:54:09 PM

Title: Warbling vinyl
Post by: that_punk_guy on July 14, 2004, 11:54:09 PM
Hmm.

So I have this new LP, with a really bad "wowing" varying pitch during playback. On side A. Side B sounds fine.

It's not entirely flat but I have more warped vinyl that plays fine and the dips don't appear to correspond with the pitch changes. And wouldn't that affect both sides? In any event I don't have a clamp. :-(

Maybe a heavier table would be enough to pull the disc round at a more consistant speed?

Gah! This is frustrating. I'm going to put it near the bottom of the pile overnight and hope some miracle happens to fix it.
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: Wain on July 15, 2004, 12:03:31 AM
I've had much success with large thick books (like big unabridged dictionaries).  Anyhow, hope it works out!
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: Speelgoedmannetje on July 15, 2004, 01:27:17 AM
Can't it be a bit of dust, or dirt from hands, since it's only on one side?
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: Cyberus on July 15, 2004, 03:34:43 AM
Quote
Warbling vinyl


When I was a kid, it was always "Slammin' Vinyl"

Sl4MMiN! (http://www.davinci-decor.com/HTML/funcart3.htm#)
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: PMC on July 15, 2004, 11:29:19 AM
Is the disk slipping on the turntable somewhere?  It's unlikely, but I guess if the vinyl is warped it's not in full contact with the rubber mat on the turntable and may be dragging somewhere?

However, you say side B sounds fine so it might be a manufacturing fault with the disk?

Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: Karlos on July 15, 2004, 11:54:19 AM
@Chris

What you need is one of those laser stylus based turntables. I kid you not, they read the groove with a laser beam and can play warped, grimy, even broken disks (if the parts are arranged correctly in the tray). Apparently the sound is as clean as you can possibly get and you only hear what has been recorded (no artifacts from your needle arm)...

Unfortunately, they cost an arm and a leg :-(
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: bloodline on July 15, 2004, 12:13:51 PM
Quote

Karlos wrote:
@Chris

What you need is one of those laser stylus based turntables. I kid you not, they read the groove with a laser beam and can play warped, grimy, even broken disks (if the parts are arranged correctly in the tray). Apparently the sound is as clean as you can possibly get and you only hear what has been recorded (no artifacts from your needle arm)...

Unfortunately, they cost an arm and a leg :-(


Yeah, about £5000... they also have a tiny vacuum on the laser armature to removed dust...

Vinyl sux, get the CD :lol:
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: Karlos on July 15, 2004, 05:47:29 PM
@Bloodline

It's a complete fallacy that CD audio is clean. Aliasing is detectable on the upper fringe of human hearing (for original signals of 22kHz+) and the dynamic range is not too great either. However, on most systems you'll never notice. On a state of the art setup (including the laser turntable), vinyl completely kicks CD's a*se...
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: odin on July 15, 2004, 06:39:34 PM
Vinyl? That's what cheap sofa's and expensive fetishes are made of, innit?

/me crawls back into his cave :-P.
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: FluffyMcDeath on July 15, 2004, 10:11:39 PM
Quote

that_punk_guy wrote:
Hmm.

So I have this new LP, with a really bad "wowing" varying pitch during playback. On side A. Side B sounds fine.



Cool. Maybe the A side was stamped off center!
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: that_punk_guy on July 15, 2004, 11:46:27 PM
Quote
Karlos wrote:
What you need is one of those laser stylus based turntables.


I remember talking to Mike about these, pretty cool and I'd like to hear one in action. Although I seem to remember reading that they aren't all-analogue and there's some D/A conversion involved.

@all

Thanks for the suggestions. Too tired to try them tonight but I will tomorrow. :-)
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: graffias79 on July 16, 2004, 05:51:04 PM
Records are groovy!

(hiding now)

:-D

-Jamie
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: that_punk_guy on July 16, 2004, 07:30:46 PM
:lol:

Well, it seems to be a few mm off-center. Am I right in thinking that towards the inside of the disc the music becomes increasingly squashed together to compensate for the shorter distance the needle is running with each spin? I guess that'd account for it.

This means contacting the guy who sold it to me, which is a case of big-time embarrassment and pride swallowing since he's (a) the singer and guitarist of the band and (b) my hero (well one of them - my other personal heroes to date include Vincent and some red-haired girl from California. If you'd like to be on my hero list, apply in writing.)

Heh. :-D

As a side-note, I came across this interesting page whilst on my travels:

http://www.kempa.com/blog/archives/000053.html
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: Cyberus on July 17, 2004, 03:21:43 AM
Quote

that_punk_guy wrote:

As a side-note, I came across this interesting page whilst on my travels:

http://www.kempa.com/blog/archives/000053.html


What's with all the porn links at the bottom? :lol:
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: that_punk_guy on July 17, 2004, 08:49:34 AM
Porn links? :-?
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: Cyberus on July 17, 2004, 12:21:11 PM
Quote

that_punk_guy wrote:
Porn links? :-?


Well, at the bottom of the page it says


Quote
young gay boys  adult gay boys  alta gay gay boys  amateur gay boys  anal gay boys  anime gay boys  art gay boys  asian gay boys  bdsm gay boys  bear gay boys  big {bleep} gay boys  bisexual gay boys  bizarre gay boys  black gay boys  blow job gay boys  bondage gay boys  boys gay boys  brutal gay boys  bukkake gay boys  cartoon gay boys  chat gay boys  {bleep} gay boys  community gay boys  cum gay boys  cumshots gay boys  {bleep} gay boys  dad gay boys  dating gay boys  dick gay boys  dildo gay boys  ebony gay boys  erotica gay boys  escort gay boys  european gay boys  exotic gay boys  extreme gay boys  fat gay boys  fetish gay boys  fi gay boys  young teen boys  adult teen boys  alta gay teen boys  amateur teen boys  anal teen boys  anime teen boys  art teen boys  asian teen boys  bdsm teen boys  bear teen boys  big {bleep} teen boys  bisexual teen boys  bizarre teen boys  black teen boys  blow job teen boys  bondage teen boys  boys teen boys  brutal teen boys  bukkake teen boys  cartoon teen boys  chat teen boys  {bleep} teen boys  community teen boys  cum teen boys  cumshots teen boys  {bleep} teen boys  dad teen boys  dating teen boys  dick teen boys  dildo teen boys  ebony teen boys  erotica teen boys  escort teen boys  european teen boys  exotic teen boys  extreme teen boys  fat teen boys  fetish teen boys  fi teen boys

asiantrans

Adorable porn incest Amateur porn incest American porn incest Anal porn incest Anime porn incest Army porn incest Asian porn incest Ass porn incest Asshole porn incest Babe porn incest Backseat porn incest Banana porn incest Banging porn incest Barely Legal porn incest Bathing porn incest BBW porn incest BDSM porn incest Beach porn incest Beauty porn incest Beaver porn incest Big {bleep} porn incest Big Tits porn incest Biker porn incest Bikini porn incest Bimbo porn incest Bisexual porn incest {bleep} porn incest Bizarre porn incest Black porn incest Blind folded porn incest Blonde porn incest Bondage porn incest Boobs porn incest Booty porn incest Bo porn incest Adorable sex incest Amateur sex incest American sex incest Anal sex incest Anime sex incest Army sex incest Asian sex incest Ass sex incest Asshole sex incest Babe sex incest Backseat sex incest Banana sex incest Banging sex incest Barely Legal sex incest Bathing sex incest BBW sex incest BDSM sex incest Beach sex incest Beauty sex incest Beaver sex incest Big {bleep} sex incest Big Tits sex incest Biker sex incest Bikini sex incest Bimbo sex incest Bisexual sex incest {bleep} sex incest Bizarre sex incest Black sex incest Blind folded sex incest Blonde sex incest Bondage sex incest Boobs sex incest Booty sex incest Bo sex incest Adorable porn mature Amateur porn mature American porn mature Anal porn mature Anime porn mature Army porn mature Asian porn mature Ass porn mature Asshole porn mature Babe porn mature Backseat porn mature Banana porn mature Banging porn mature Barely Legal porn mature Bathing porn mature BBW porn mature BDSM porn mature Beach porn mature Beauty porn mature Beaver porn mature Big {bleep} porn mature Big Tits porn mature Biker porn mature Bikini porn mature Bimbo porn mature Bisexual porn mature {bleep} porn mature Bizarre porn mature Black porn mature Blind folded porn mature Blonde porn mature Bondage porn mature Boobs porn mature Booty porn mature Bo porn mature Adorable sex mature Amateur sex mature American sex mature Anal sex mature Anime sex mature Army sex mature Asian sex mature Ass sex mature Asshole sex mature Babe sex mature Backseat sex mature Banana sex mature Banging sex mature Barely Legal sex mature Bathing sex mature BBW sex mature BDSM sex mature Beach sex mature Beauty sex mature Beaver sex mature Big {bleep} sex mature Big Tits sex mature Biker sex mature Bikini sex mature Bimbo sex mature Bisexual sex mature {bleep} sex mature Bizarre sex mature Black sex mature Blind folded sex mature Blonde sex mature Bondage sex mature Boobs sex mature Booty sex mature Bo sex mature Adorable free incest Amateur free incest American free incest Anal free incest Anime free incest Army free incest Asian free incest Ass free incest Asshole free incest Babe free incest Backseat free incest Banana free incest Banging free incest Barely Legal free incest Bathing free incest BBW free incest BDSM free incest Beach free incest Beauty free incest Beaver free incest Big {bleep} free incest Big Tits free incest Biker free incest Bikini free incest Bimbo free incest Bisexual free incest {bleep} free incest Bizarre free incest Black free incest Blind folded free incest Blonde free incest Bondage free incest Boobs free incest Booty free incest Bo free incest Adorable free mature Amateur free mature American free mature Anal free mature Anime free mature Army free mature Asian free mature Ass free mature Asshole free mature Babe free mature Backseat free mature Banana free mature Banging free mature Barely Legal free mature Bathing free mature BBW free mature BDSM free mature Beach free mature Beauty free mature Beaver free mature Big {bleep} free mature Big Tits free mature Biker free mature Bikini free mature Bimbo free mature Bisexual free mature {bleep} free mature Bizarre free mature Black free mature Blind folded free mature Blonde free mature Bondage free mature Boobs free mature Booty free mature Bo free mature

hard-boys

young gay boys adult gay boys alta gay gay boys amateur gay boys anal gay boys anime gay boys art gay boys asian gay boys bdsm gay boys bear gay boys big {bleep} gay boys bisexual gay boys bizarre gay boys black gay boys blow job gay boys bondage gay boys boys gay boys brutal gay boys bukkake gay boys cartoon gay boys chat gay boys {bleep} gay boys community gay boys cum gay boys cumshots gay boys {bleep} gay boys dad gay boys dating gay boys dick gay boys dildo gay boys ebony gay boys erotica gay boys escort gay boys european gay boys exotic gay boys extreme gay boys fat gay boys fetish gay boys fi gay boys young teen boys adult teen boys alta gay teen boys amateur teen boys anal teen boys anime teen boys art teen boys asian teen boys bdsm teen boys bear teen boys big {bleep} teen boys bisexual teen boys bizarre teen boys black teen boys blow job teen boys bondage teen boys boys teen boys brutal teen boys bukkake teen boys cartoon teen boys chat teen boys {bleep} teen boys community teen boys cum teen boys cumshots teen boys {bleep} teen boys dad teen boys dating teen boys dick teen boys dildo teen boys ebony teen boys erotica teen boys escort teen boys european teen boys exotic teen boys extreme teen boys fat teen boys fetish teen boys fi teen boys
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: that_punk_guy on July 17, 2004, 12:33:08 PM
:-o

That wasn't there when I posted it!! I must have had the page cached too.
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: odin on July 17, 2004, 01:14:42 PM
Plain simple guestbook spammage.
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: T_Bone on July 17, 2004, 01:15:29 PM
Quote

that_punk_guy wrote:
:-o

That wasn't there when I posted it!! I must have had the page cached too.


Sure ;-)
:lol:
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: bloodline on July 17, 2004, 03:27:52 PM
Quote

Karlos wrote:
@Bloodline

It's a complete fallacy that CD audio is clean. Aliasing is detectable on the upper fringe of human hearing (for original signals of 22kHz+) and the dynamic range is not too great either. However, on most systems you'll never notice. On a state of the art setup (including the laser turntable), vinyl completely kicks CD's a*se...


You forget that the Speed at which the Record rotates and the size of the stylus limits the highest frequency that can be recorded on Vinyl. Vinyl sux just as much as CDs do in the recorded quality, but they also suffer from far more physical problems (re this thread :-D) too...
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: that_punk_guy on July 17, 2004, 08:52:18 PM
Have any connoisseurs of high technology here heard DVD-Audio yet?
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: bloodline on July 17, 2004, 09:11:43 PM
Quote

that_punk_guy wrote:
Have any connoisseurs of high technology here heard DVD-Audio yet?


Of course :-)

And yes it is vastly superior to CD's, especially on a good system (Expensive Amp and Speakers).

-Edit- Mixing a song using 24bit @96Khz give you some much more headroom that CD-Audio that it makes life musch easier, similar to what it was like on Analog mixing boards.
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: Turambar on July 19, 2004, 06:55:29 PM
Yep im with bloodline, vinyl sucks. I sell it. It's {bleep}. Those who praise vinyl have never had to file as much of the stuff as i have clearly.
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: Wain on July 20, 2004, 01:56:23 AM
Records make for better symphonic recordings by and large.  The additional warmth that is often present makes it preferred for most audiophiles when dealing with certain recording situations.

In the end, all recording formats are limited, and vinyl and CD are both very good at different things.

@TPG
audio is not compressed at the middle of a record, there is simply less room for information because the rotational speed doesn't change...or did I misunderstand your question?
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: that_punk_guy on July 20, 2004, 09:34:01 PM
What I meant was that since the outside of the disc moves a lot faster than the inside, that physically each second of audio occupies a shorter distance on the groove. So if you played the groove linear somehow, it would steadily increase in pitch. That would account for the varying pitch where the groove isn't concentric with the centre hole.

Um, that's if I'm right. My head hurts, I'm not sure, heh. :-)
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: Dr_Righteous on July 21, 2004, 04:55:15 AM
Vinyl would be perfect if it were sealed in a container like a hard disk to keep it dust free... Analog recording beats digital sampling any day.

But who really cares anyway? If you're playing it as loud as you're supposed to, NO ONE can tell!
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: Wain on July 22, 2004, 12:27:01 AM
Quote

that_punk_guy wrote:
What I meant was that since the outside of the disc moves a lot faster than the inside, that physically each second of audio occupies a shorter distance on the groove. So if you played the groove linear somehow, it would steadily increase in pitch. That would account for the varying pitch where the groove isn't concentric with the centre hole.

Um, that's if I'm right. My head hurts, I'm not sure, heh. :-)


Oh, I get what you're talking about now.  

Yes, record players use CAV (Constant Angular Velocity). The needle has to travel a greater distance at the edge than it does near the center, because of this the linear velocity is different depending on the location of the needle, hence the throughput is different too.  

So YES, if a record is stamped off-center, it will sound all sorts of warbly-messed up because the throughput changes irregularly as the needle moves closer and farther away from the center, instead of smoothly closer the way the a properly centered record would.
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: Wain on July 22, 2004, 02:05:27 AM
Quote
But who really cares anyway? If you're playing it as loud as you're supposed to, NO ONE can tell!


don't forget the warmth issue though.  Symphonic recordings usually sound better on a record no contest.
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: that_punk_guy on July 22, 2004, 09:32:26 PM
I find myself sitting on the fence really with the analogue/digital debate. I remember the first time I heard vinyl on a good system, my uncle had this big Pioneer system. This is when those standalone cabinet hi-fis were still the norm, and I'd grown up with the hype about CD's superiority. I just thought vinyl was supposed to sound like crap, and it blew me away.

So while I never became an audiophile (in fact the most time I get to listen to music these days is on the move... in mp3) it's still an interest. (My vinyl collection's pretty small though.)

This is why DVD-Audio (and SACD) interests me, although I can't help thinking, what if they had waited a little while longer and gone for an even higher resolution? I hope they left the door open for higher bitrates in those formats, anyway.

I don't like the encryption though.

I'm rambling and it's not very interesting, but I'm trying to talk about something other than politics and racism for a while.  :-D
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: Speelgoedmannetje on July 22, 2004, 09:38:43 PM
Quote

that_punk_guy wrote:
So while I never became an audiophile (in fact the most time I get to listen to music these days is on the move... in mp3) it's still an interest. (My vinyl collection's pretty small though.)
try ogg vorbis
I must say this format gives quite a satisfying clear sound
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: that_punk_guy on July 22, 2004, 09:44:27 PM
Well my current player's mp3-only. Just a cheap CD-based thing. But I have been eyeing up an iRiver (iPod clone) which supports Ogg. Maybe when I'm rich.
Title: Re: Warbling vinyl
Post by: Speelgoedmannetje on July 22, 2004, 09:50:47 PM
oh, I was thinking of just playing it from the computer (misread your post a bit)