SlimJim,
I agree with most of your post, particularly the point about the economies of scale in the Amiga market.
However, if we are to rely on homegrown software to start with I would hope that those developers look to the current PC market to find their target, just as Paybacks' developers did. In that sense a wishlist is a good idea.
I know that a bedroom coder has no chance of knocking out a near perfect copy of Vice City or Metal Gear Solid, but Pacman and Defender and all those other types of game have been done to death. It's time to start "pushing the envelope", perhaps starting with a port of Duke Nukem now the source is available.
Most of the games I mentioned are part of a series that has expanded or have an active mod community which means that once the base game is ported there are many more opportunities available. Putting aside the diffuculties you mentioned, once you convert Half-Life you have the chance of Opposing Force, Blue Shift, Counter Strike, Gunman Chronicles etc.
As for the OS not yet being available, OS4 does not offer many more gaming APIs over 3.9, AFAIK only amigainput and Warp3D NOVA, so work really could be underway at the moment. If speed is an issue use Amithlon.
The Amiga story is one of dreams and financial loss, look at Jay Miners accounts ot the pre Commodore days. If they had been realistic the Amiga would never have made it to market.
If we all sit down and look at this realistically, well, there is no future for Amiga is there? The hardware is underspecced and overpriced, the software is late or non-existant, the competition has a strangle hold on the market that even govenrnment cannot release.
This is the reality. The truth is that Amiga is already dead. It will take a miracle to get Amigas on sale in high streets, to get big name developers to code for this platform. We can either face up to the truth, in which case we may as well give up now, or we can dream a little.
I'm going to dream, you do what you want.
Please, no more doom givers posting here. This topic is for dreamers only.