I can see both sides of the coin here. However, I think as much as I would probably appreciate this type of a thread, I'm gonna have to side with the mods.
My main reason is because I'm sure it's already a PITA moderating such a large forum in the first place. The guidelines are no secret :rtfm:, everyone has had to read them. If the mods are doing their part, as in warnings and the like, I think perhaps we should just trust them