Varthall wrote:
Shouldn't an AmigaOne or a Sam be able to manage modern video editing?
Varthall
A more appropriate question would be 'Is anyone going to program a modern video editing system for the AmigaOne or Sam'
I've used Avid Media Composer on a Mac G3 doing News Promo's and a 1 hour weekly real estate show several years ago - so you could say it *COULD* be done.
Will it though? That's another question entirely.
For the amount of work that would be required to go into it, it would have to be commerciallly viable - which means competing with products available today.
Not easy, but not impossible.. Final Cut has been able to do this. Not too many years ago it wasn't taken very seriously at all - a lot of places I've worked with and for considered it a 'toy' for home use only. This year we have replaced 3 out of 4 edit bays with Final Cut Pro.
Mind you that would involve looking at what is available, and improving on it. Again this isn't impossible. Avid had the foresight to design its interface around people who actually edit - which although not immediately intuitive, once you actually do the work is a joy to use - hotkeys are placed logically in groups based on frequency of use in actual editing.. they understood that your one hand will leave the keyboard to use the mouse and other such things.
Final Cut is more designed by programmers - my hands 'cross over' - things that can slow you down..
On the flipside Final Cut is a dream to work with when going back and forth between things such as photoshop and after effects. it's clip manipulation on the timeline I think is better and easier to use as well.
If a new program were to be made, its designers would do well to find these things that seem to work well on one system or another system and bring these features together.
This being said, there seems to be a near bullish resistance to change when it comes to the Amiga nowadays, and if the solution were simply a rebadged and tooled toaster - it would be doomed to failure - NOBODY wants to go back to the 'bad old days' of scopes and mixers. The paradigm has changed....for the better.
In fact my boss came to me several months ago, knowing I was a Amiga enthusiast from the old days and put it to me 'Could you imagine still using Video Toaster for this?'
My reply was 'If you ever made me - I'd slit my wrists and bleed out on the edit bay floor'.