Great thread
I remember those days when Electronics Boutique had a small selection of Amiga games and buying Teacksuit Manager 2 96/97.
I also had an ST, at the time games for it were less commecially available than they were for the Amiga (I brought bad luck to any system I bought) and remember buying games that, although boxed, came with a hand written disk label.
They used to have a wonderful catalogue with lists of games. How I miss this and Special Reserve.
The worst game I had for my Amiga was Championship Manager 2. So much hype, yet when I finally got it the game was unusable.
Maybe it was a great game, but it was my biggest disappointment.