AB3D 1 is also groovy on WinUAE. AB3D 2 still doesn't work correctly, and perhaps that's for the best.
Using the sacred Bible (well, it is to me) that is Amiga Power (they gave Rise of the Robots the lowest mark of the Amiga magazines, thanks), AB3D gets 91%, simply put at the end: "Doom, but on the amiga. My word."
AB3D 2, reviewed in the last issue, got a slightly confusing range of score from 54% to 'somewhere in the mid-60s, if you have an Amiga fast enough to run it.' So there you go. Sister magazine Amiga Format got excited and gave it 96%...