"Memory defrag" patches and newer execs

[AmigaMance]

Hi.
 Since the memory allocation routines has changed in piru's exec44 and exec45 of AmigaOS to reduce memory fragmentation, i want to ask if simple memory defrag patches like fragless and fragcure are still useful or obsolete.

 Also: I've heard that these patches (or is it PoolMem?) can cause serious HD corruption with some FileSystems like PFS. Is this true?

[AmiDude]

@AmigaMance

I'm using FragCure on My A4000/060-OS3.9-BB2
system without any problems. It actually defragments
the memory into larger blocks. If I don't have
the FragCure command in my startup-sequence,
the memory is more fragmented. So for me it's
still useful!
 :-)

[Piru]

@AmigaMance

Since the memory allocation routines has changed in piru's exec44 and exec45 of AmigaOS to reduce memory fragmentation, i want to ask if simple memory defrag patches like fragless and fragcure are still useful or obsolete.

They are still useful.

Also: I've heard that these patches (or is it PoolMem?) can cause serious HD corruption with some FileSystems like PFS. Is this true?

That's nonsense (the often repeated claim is that poolmem  would cause corruption with pfs3). I used PoolMem and PFS3 for years, and never had any problems.

Also afaik fragless and fragcure just play with MEMF_REVERSE. That is safe for sure...

[AmigaMance]

 I did some tests yesterday and i got some contradictive results.
 My test was to run a program which tends to fragment my ram for a while, quit the program and then use a utility to measure the fragmentation degree of my memory. The program  (game in this case) was Heretic 2 and the frag reporting utility was AmigaLoad.
 The interesting thing was that i get a 10% of fragmentation with theb FragCure patch installed and 6% without it. Strange.. Perhaps AmigaLoad doesn't give reliable results?

[Piru]

@AmigaMance

I'd blame Heretic 2 rather. Does it even return all memory to system at exit?

[AmigaMance]

I'd blame Heretic 2 rather.

I wouldn't know but i can say that the Amiga version of the game is less than perfect.

Does it even return all memory to system at exit?

Yes. Well, almost. After i quit and do a memory flush, i have only 200kb less fast ram.