For some reason I have had no problems at all with the Escom disk drive. Even the few really old games I have work fine.
When Escom took over the production of the A1200 from Commodore, there were many partly built machines still in the production plant as well as lots of components, including disk drives.
Therefore until the stock ran out, the Escom A1200 came with a proper Amiga floppy drive. It's only after they coudn't source more supplies that they started using PC drives.
Lotus 2 and 3 never worked for me on my unexpanded A1200, but when I bought an 8meg trapdoor board they worked fine...I guess they just needed some fastram.
I have an expanded A1200 with 8MB Fast Ram and some of the games I listed will work sometimes but as it's not everytime, I use my A500 or A600 machines for these games as they are guaranteed to work.
have gotten all but one or two games to work on my 1200, the one I have a problem with is Mega lo Mania, it seems to crash after a bit, and I can't get Moonstone to work no matter what!
I forgot Mega lo Mania. Great Game. I coun't get that one to work on A1200 or A4000 either. Seems to only like 1.3 the best. Crashes a bit on 2.0 systems as well. Moonstone freezes during booting and goes no further.
One thought, my Commodore A1200 has 3.0 Roms and Escom A1200's have 3.1 Roms. This might lead to some games working on some machines and not others. There were also some MoBo revisions. The last being the worst if I remember correctly.
With an A1200 and fastram, I've gotten pretty much all of the old games to work, a few of them just need some extreme coaxing and combination of degraders. Sometimes hours of ridiculous trial and error just for a stupid old game I don't even play afterwards!
I know what you mean. I used to spend ages trying to get games working with every combination I could think of. The most annoying was when I couldn't get an HD installed game to work on either my A4000 or A1200. And after so long I have forgotten how I got some of them to work which is really annoying.
On my A4000, Worms won't run. It gets so far and then just stops. Not sure of the problem. Not really bothered as I have Worms on DC, GBA and PC as well.