Amiga.org

Amiga News and Community Announcements => Amiga News and Community Announcements => Topic started by: SysAdmin on April 01, 2012, 04:52:47 PM

Title: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: SysAdmin on April 01, 2012, 04:52:47 PM
News from AmigaKit via amigaworld.net

We are currently collecting details for customers interested in the next production run of AmigaOne X1000 (http://amigakit.leamancomputing.com/x1000/), due in the Q2 2012.

Customers that were not successful in the first batch do not need to contact us as we have already given them priority for the second batch.



If you wish to purchase an AmigaOne X1000, please goto the product website (http://www.amigakit.com/x1000), register your interest and we will then contact you by email once ordering is open in next quarter.

Note that at this stage, you are not placing an order- you are just registering interest in the product.

AmigaOne X1000 Product Website:

http://www.amigakit.com/x1000
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Darrin on April 01, 2012, 05:03:05 PM
Done!
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: klx300r on April 01, 2012, 06:27:35 PM
what! this is too good to be true! none of the usual suspects trolling on this thread yet :-)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: ribdevil1 on April 01, 2012, 06:41:15 PM
Quote from: klx300r;686407
what! this is too good to be true! none of the usual suspects trolling on this thread yet :-)

It's Sunday, and they are too lazy, but just wait, and see.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: SysAdmin on April 01, 2012, 06:44:04 PM
People that have purchased a received a Amiga X-1000 are happy. At the end of the day that's all that really matters. Trolls will be trolls and were never going to buy anything anyway. I bet many trolls never even owned an Amiga.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: TheDaddy on April 01, 2012, 07:00:20 PM
Quote from: klx300r;686407
what! this is too good to be true! none of the usual suspects trolling on this thread yet :-)


I am going to spare them the effort:

"Overpriced piece of junk and OS."

There... ;)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: persia on April 01, 2012, 07:08:57 PM
Quote from: transition;686410
people that have purchased a received a amiga x-1000 are happy. At the end of the day that's all that really matters. Trolls will be trolls and were never going to buy anything anyway. I bet many trolls never even owned an amiga.


april fools!
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Iggy on April 01, 2012, 09:07:08 PM
Quote from: persia;686416
april fools!

No they are actually getting ready to release a new run.
I registered yesterday on March 3!st.

BTW - Way to go Darrin!
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Iggy on April 01, 2012, 09:08:39 PM
Quote from: TheDaddy;686412
I am going to spare them the effort:

"Overpriced piece of junk and OS."

There... ;)

And again. Trolling.
And as far as overpriced junk goes, there's plenty of legacy hardware available on Ebay right now.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: TheDaddy on April 02, 2012, 08:01:06 AM
Quote from: Iggy;686424
And again. Trolling.
And as far as overpriced junk goes, there's plenty of legacy hardware available on Ebay right now.

Like this:

Here (http://www.ebay.co.uk/ctg/Apple-Mac-Mini-Desktop-M9971B-B-July-2005-/78699651?_dmpt=UK_Computing_Apple_Desktops_CV&_pcategid=4603&_pcatid=586&_refkw=mac+mini+powerpc&_trkparms=65%253A12%257C66%253A2%257C39%253A1%257C72%253A6003&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14)

:)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: darkage on April 02, 2012, 08:21:54 AM
How much does the X1000 retail for ?
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: takemehomegrandma on April 02, 2012, 10:16:52 AM
Quote from: darkage;686507
How much does the X1000 retail for ?


This much:

(http://farm8.staticflickr.com/7059/6892045166_eae890172c_b.jpg)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: drHirudo on April 02, 2012, 10:38:10 AM
Quote from: takemehomegrandma;686511
This much:



PowerMac doesn't run AmigaOS ---> Not interested.
PowerBooks and G5 Macs don't run AmigaOS alike OSes either ---> Fail.

ʎɐʍɐ ʞɔnɟ oƃ
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: mikeymike on April 02, 2012, 10:38:14 AM
@ takemehomegrandma

Isn't that an image of a PowerMac G4?  Weren't those about $3000 USD new?
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Kesa on April 02, 2012, 10:45:25 AM
Quote from: takemehomegrandma;686511
This much:

(http://farm8.staticflickr.com/7059/6892045166_eae890172c_b.jpg)

What is an A1X1K?
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Duce on April 02, 2012, 11:00:08 AM
Quote from: mikeymike;686513
@ takemehomegrandma

Isn't that an image of a PowerMac G4?  Weren't those about $3000 USD new?


Don't confuse him with facts or we are likely to get more graphs and diagrams based on false logic and tall tales.  

:lol:
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: takemehomegrandma on April 02, 2012, 11:11:27 AM
Quote from: mikeymike;686513
@ takemehomegrandma

Isn't that an image of a PowerMac G4?  Weren't those about $3000 USD new?


Who knows, who cares, they cost about $25-$250 (http://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_trksid=p5197.m570.l1313&_nkw=powermac+g4&_sacat=See-All-Categories) now, mostly seem around the $100 mark, give or take. And redrumloa just got a cheap CPU replacement (http://www.morphzone.org/modules/newbb_plus/viewtopic.php?topic_id=8417&forum=11#90696) for his, probably putting it among the fastest PPC *migas available now... :)


Quote from: Kesa;686514
What is an A1X1K?


Try to figure it out! :) (Hint, it's a short for the name of the machine the topic is about ;))


Quote from: Duce;686515
Don't confuse him with facts or we are likely to get more graphs and diagrams based on false logic and tall tales.


Sorry, can't help you there... :)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Piru on April 02, 2012, 12:06:53 PM
Quote from: Duce;686515
graphs and diagrams based on false logic and tall tales.

Which graphs you're referring to?

Any of the below have something wrong with them?

lame benchmark
(http://sintonen.fi/pics/lame_benchmark.png)

mplayer benchmark
(http://sintonen.fi/pics/mplayer_benchmark.png)

dnetc benchmark
(http://sintonen.fi/pics/dnetc_benchmark.png)

blender benchmark
(http://sintonen.fi/pics/blender_benchmark.png)

68k emulation benchmark
(http://sintonen.fi/pics/68kemu_benchmark.png)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: billyfish on April 02, 2012, 01:07:27 PM
Quote
Sorry, can't help you there... :)


With the content of your posts on threads such as these, I'm fairly sure you can't help me anywhere! :-)

Seriously, why are you so bothered by the X1000? Why do you care so much if people want to buy it or not? I'm genuinely interested in your motivation. It doesn't make any difference to me if people want to buy this, a power mac or a dead parrot as long as they're happy with their purchase, that's great.

As for any performance of the X1000, I quote from http://blog.hyperion-entertainment.biz/?p=580

"Given the rushed nature of this AmigaOS 4.1 Update 5 release, there are still some bugs and a few rough edges. Remember, the X1000 was originally planned to be released only with AmigaOS 4.2 installed. Also please keep in mind most of the X1000 system is still unoptimized. This is truly the most powerful Amiga Operating System hardware platform ever released and we plan to utilize this hardware to its full potential in due course."

Basically wait until the software is fully optimized for the X1000 before analysing performance too deeply.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: persia on April 02, 2012, 01:25:51 PM
There is an almost magical number of 500, €500, £500, US$500, AUD500, that people are willing to part with fairly easily on technology.  There's a reason for the iPad's USD499 price.  A 500 level price on new AmigaOS equipment would attract many of us who are not currently attracted to a £1900 machine.....
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: mikeymike on April 02, 2012, 01:28:33 PM
Quote from: takemehomegrandma;686517
Who knows, who cares, they cost about $25-$250 (http://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_trksid=p5197.m570.l1313&_nkw=powermac+g4&_sacat=See-All-Categories) now, mostly seem around the $100 mark, give or take.

So you're comparing two debatably over-priced items (when new), but to try and validate your point about price, you're comparing a second-hand approx. ten year old Mac with a brand-new X1000.

It would be almost a complete miracle for a company to manage to build a general-purpose computer that isn't x86/x64 for a sum that many wouldn't regard to be bad value compared to x86/x64.  I couldn't care less if people want to buy a Mac (or Amiga, or any other computer) despite a similar-spec PC costing significantly less.  If that purchase is satisfactory in their opinion, and dishonest claims aren't being made, I'm happy for those users.  I'm trying to figure out why you care so much that you regularly have to come here and troll, because that's what you're doing.  Having said that, I think it's more likely that you simply do it for your own amusement, hence your "who knows, who cares" comment.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: itix on April 02, 2012, 01:29:53 PM
Quote from: billyfish;686522
With the content of your posts on threads such as these, I'm fairly sure you can't help me anywhere! :-)

Seriously, why are you so bothered by the X1000? Why do you care so much if people want to buy it or not? I'm genuinely interested in your motivation. It doesn't make any difference to me if people want to buy this, a power mac or a dead parrot as long as they're happy with their purchase, that's great.

As for any performance of the X1000, I quote from http://blog.hyperion-entertainment.biz/?p=580

"Given the rushed nature of this AmigaOS 4.1 Update 5 release, there are still some bugs and a few rough edges. Remember, the X1000 was originally planned to be released only with AmigaOS 4.2 installed. Also please keep in mind most of the X1000 system is still unoptimized. This is truly the most powerful Amiga Operating System hardware platform ever released and we plan to utilize this hardware to its full potential in due course."

Basically wait until the software is fully optimized for the X1000 before analysing performance too deeply.


Someone asked how much A1X1K costs and so far takemehomegrandma's answer was closest one.

The performance figure "A1X1K is roughly as fast as PowerMac" is also correct and not contradicting with the official Hyperion statement "the most powerful Amiga Operating System hardware platform ever released" at all. A1X1K is the fastest Amiga Operating System Hardware you can buy. Not fastest Amiga obviously but Hyperion never claimed that :-)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: itix on April 02, 2012, 01:31:19 PM
Quote from: darkage;686507
How much does the X1000 retail for ?


About $3200 if you are in the US.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: jorkany on April 02, 2012, 02:09:39 PM
Quote from: billyfish;686522
"Given the rushed nature of this AmigaOS 4.1 Update 5 release, there are still some bugs and a few rough edges. Remember, the X1000 was originally planned to be released only with AmigaOS 4.2 installed. Also please keep in mind most of the X1000 system is still unoptimized. This is truly the most powerful Amiga Operating System hardware platform ever released and we plan to utilize this hardware to its full potential in due course."

Awesome! Maybe somebody can start a bounty to get the drivers written and OS4 out of beta!

By the way, whatever happened to the contractor who was writing the XMOS support for OS4?
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: drHirudo on April 02, 2012, 02:40:38 PM
Haha, it's always the same on Amiga dot org.

Thread about AmigaOS 4 software/hardware news appears, it's gets polluted very fast with MOS/Mac propaganda and derail in off-topic in no time.

This is not Vintage Mac forum. It's Amiga forum for discussing Amiga hardware/clones - Amiga 500, 1000, 1200, 4000, Minimig, Draco, AmigaOne, Sam etc., i.e. vintage and new machines.

Okay, to keep the tradition of going off topic - I am still waiting for my PowerBook (http://hirudov.com/apple/PowerBookG4.php) to be able to run MOS.

Nobody wrote drivers for it yet? Maybe somebody can start a bounty to get the drivers written and MOS 3 out!
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: CritAnime on April 02, 2012, 02:40:49 PM
I wish I had the money for one :(
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: number6 on April 02, 2012, 02:52:27 PM
Quote from: takemehomegrandma;686517
Try to figure it out! :) (Hint, it's a short for the name of the machine the topic is about ;))Sorry, can't help you there... :)



Nope.
The topic is...
"Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000".

You obviously confused this with the "registering DISinterest" thread.
I assume the "can't help you there" was a cry for help in trying to understanding the actual thread topic.

#6
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: billyfish on April 02, 2012, 03:03:41 PM
Quote from: itix
Someone asked how much A1X1K costs and so far takemehomegrandma's answer was closest one.


30 PowerMacs? As currency goes, it's a little bit cumbersome! :-)

Quote

The performance figure "A1X1K is roughly as fast as PowerMac" is also correct and not contradicting with the official Hyperion statement "the most powerful Amiga Operating System hardware platform ever released" at all. A1X1K is the fastest Amiga Operating System Hardware you can buy. Not fastest Amiga obviously but Hyperion never claimed that :-)


The relevant part was actually "Also please keep in mind most of the X1000 system is still unoptimized." My point is, as with any software, when it's in beta, it's not generally going to be running at the same speed as in its final polished state.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: darkage on April 02, 2012, 03:08:59 PM
Geeez $3200 USD!  I think I'll buy that 2nd hand car I've been thinking about instead.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: spirantho on April 02, 2012, 03:36:20 PM
That's better. This thread is now complete.

I was worried for a moment, it seemed like the trolls had forgotten us. :)

Now can we please get back on topic?
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: klx300r on April 02, 2012, 04:00:06 PM
Quote from: spirantho;686539
That's better. This thread is now complete.

I was worried for a moment, it seemed like the trolls had forgotten us. :)

Now can we please get back on topic?


:laughing:...yup the usual suspects seem to be getting slower.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: takemehomegrandma on April 02, 2012, 04:03:10 PM
Quote from: mikeymike;686525
So you're comparing two debatably over-priced items (when new), but to try and validate your point about price


It's really not very complicated at all mikeymike, the only relevant comparison for anyone thinking of buying a NG system *today*, are what options are available *today* (not a decade ago, not a decade into the future when/if OS4 finally supports the HW fully)! I'm talking about hardware availability, hardware price, hardware performance, hardware quality, what features the OS has, what Amiga Standards (like MUI, Poseidon, CGX, etc) the OS has, the performance of the OS, the level of Amiga compatibility in the OS, the stability of the OS, etc. Learning things like this, might help you make a well educated purchase decision, *not* having access to this kind of info may lead to people being fooled to buy a $3,000+ system while being of the wrong impression that it would be the only or the best alternative. Knowledge is good! :)

Quote
you're comparing a second-hand approx. ten year old Mac with a brand-new X1000.


The motherboard design may be new, but the core PA6T was created in 2005 to be ready for laptops in 2007, but got shelved after Apple went x86 and bought PA Semi for the competence and pulled the plug on the PPC things, so it's at least half a decade old technology, aimed for mobile/power saving applications, and all this clearly shows in benchmarks.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: klx300r on April 02, 2012, 04:09:10 PM
Quote from: Piru;686520
Which graphs you're referring to?

Any of the below have something wrong with them?
l


can you please start a new thread entiled "benchmark graphs outlining the X1000 in an unoptimized state and only running one one 1 core"

even better please post it at the Apple recycling website.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: klx300r on April 02, 2012, 04:14:23 PM
Quote from: mikeymike;686525
....  I'm trying to figure out why you care so much that you regularly have to come here and troll, because that's what you're doing.  Having said that, I think it's more likely that you simply do it for your own amusement, hence your "who knows, who cares" comment.


:drink: mate I think you better save this response as you can save time by cutting & pasting it into EVERY single OS4.x related thread on this site.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: takemehomegrandma on April 02, 2012, 04:25:27 PM
Quote from: number6;686535
The topic is...
"Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000".


Why this über-sensitiveness about topics all the sudden? Judging by your über-strict views on topic-discipline, only post #2 was on topic (since it was Darrin "Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000", which by your definition would be the only posts allowed), and *every single* subsequent post was off topic, including yours! If that would have been the only thing allowed, then you could as well lock this thread and let it fall back into the history. But reading the topic in a more common-sense/humane way, it could be construed as a discussion about another upcoming batch or A1X1K might be on its way and people who would be interested in it should act now. Naturally discussions about price, availability etc will comes up, and can be discussed, all on topic. I find the A1X1K price to be almost criminally high, especially when looking at the alternatives available, so when someone asked for the price, I made that picture illustrating what it costs compared to the alternatives, and also what you get for your money when it comes to performance. A picture says more than a thousand words, sorry you didn't like it, but there is no reason for you to play the "off-topic-crybaby" card. This is a discussion board, meant for discussions...
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: billyfish on April 02, 2012, 04:29:02 PM
Quote from: jorkany;686529
Awesome! Maybe somebody can start a bounty to get the drivers written and OS4 out of beta!


Sigh, do you realise how long these things take to write, debug, optimise, etc? It's hard work. OS4, MorphOS and AROS are all playing catch up with regards to fully supporting the hardware, e.g sound card drivers for the 460, wireless support for the Mac Mini, etc. The issue's the same: do they wait until everything's fully finished (if such a thing exists with software...) or release it in state with rough edges?

I've had many years of being a programmer in that lovely, shiny boat and generally speaking it's a "damned if we do, damned if we don't" situation

Quote
By the way, whatever happened to the contractor who was writing the XMOS support for OS4?


No idea, but since it's nothing to do with me, I'm not surprised that they don't give me daily reports.

Same question as I asked grandma: why do you care so much about the X1000 and/or OS4? I assume you've no interest in buying one so why do you care if others do?
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: billyfish on April 02, 2012, 04:36:52 PM
Quote from: takemehomegrandma;686545
This is a discussion board, meant for discussions...


Ok I'll repeat my question as part of this discursive joy: why do you care so much about something that you clearly have no intention of buying and won't affect you in any physical way? I'm fairly sure it's not like a puppy gets killed every time someone buys an X1000. I'm willing to guarantee that no animals were harmed during the making of the X1000 or OS4 if that helps you.

As for my response to the original topic, and to quote Darrin, DONE!
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: OlafS3 on April 02, 2012, 04:51:48 PM
why? He loves to tell everyone (expecially those who are not interested in) that MorphOS is the best OS, has the most (and best) users and developers, most and best software and runs on the best hardware. Short: "MorphOS rulez the world". Still questions? :-)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Piru on April 02, 2012, 04:56:04 PM
Quote from: klx300r;686543
can you please start a new thread entiled "benchmark graphs outlining the X1000 in an unoptimized state and only running one one 1 core"
I'll rather post it to "comparing MorphOS on quad core G5 vs AmigaOS 4 on dual core X1000" thread which would make as much sense, i.e. none.

Quote
even better please post it at the Apple recycling website.
I know it's hard to accept that 5+ years old apple HW can beat your favorite, and is a lot cheaper, and is more easily available, and has better support and repair possibilities...
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: OlafS3 on April 02, 2012, 05:01:12 PM
Red versus blue starts again. I will fetch Popcorn :-)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: eliyahu on April 02, 2012, 05:04:20 PM
@thread

you know what's funny? when i saw this posted originally, i figured that less than twenty-four hours in, piru and TMHG would be all over it. and when i checked it this morning, guess who i saw?

:laughing:

they just can't help themselves. every OS4 thread, without exception, here they come, like the plague.

well done, chaps. again you manage to demonstrate your vast superiority. we are in awe at your brilliance, your prescience; we stand dismayed that we should dare use something other than the great and might MOS on apple hardware. one butterfly to rule them all.... :lol:

-- eliyahu
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: OlafS3 on April 02, 2012, 05:07:00 PM
at least you accept your inferiority and your defeat :-)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: darkage on April 02, 2012, 05:13:44 PM
Talk about holy wars! :)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: eliyahu on April 02, 2012, 05:16:09 PM
Quote from: OlafS3;686552
at least you accept your inferiority and your defeat :-)
oh, absolutely. if only i would listen to the magnificent, cogent arguments of the holy piru and his disciple TMHG, who try in vain at every opportunity to turn me from my wicked path.

and here i am, foolishly thinking that this announcement from amigakit was good news. i even emailed to sign up, signaling my willingness to pony up $3000 for such an inferior, pitiable machine. how idiotic of me to want to use something i enjoy, rather than something they enjoy.

i'm sure they'll be back here shortly, ready and willing to explain to me for the 2,176th time how that was a bad move and i should submit to the mighty tide of MOS and used mac hardware. any minute now. :lol:

-- eliyahu
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: OlafS3 on April 02, 2012, 05:18:29 PM
at least you understand it now :lol:

i personal would not buy X1000 and I am not interested in PPC Macs but I accept that people think different. And i already find it funny when the "religious" wars are starting...
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: mikeymike on April 02, 2012, 05:41:47 PM
Quote from: takemehomegrandma;686542
It's really not very complicated at all mikeymike, the only relevant comparison for anyone thinking of buying a NG system *today*, are what options are available *today* (not a decade ago, not a decade into the future when/if OS4 finally supports the HW fully)! I'm talking about hardware availability, hardware price, hardware performance, hardware quality, what features the OS has, what Amiga Standards (like MUI, Poseidon, CGX, etc) the OS has, the performance of the OS, the level of Amiga compatibility in the OS, the stability of the OS, etc. Learning things like this, might help you make a well educated purchase decision, *not* having access to this kind of info may lead to people being fooled to buy a $3,000+ system while being of the wrong impression that it would be the only or the best alternative. Knowledge is good! :)

The motherboard design may be new, but the core PA6T was created in 2005 to be ready for laptops in 2007, but got shelved after Apple went x86 and bought PA Semi for the competence and pulled the plug on the PPC things, so it's at least half a decade old technology, aimed for mobile/power saving applications, and all this clearly shows in benchmarks.

To begin with, a straight-forward question was asked, how much does the X1000 retail for.  There wasn't any ambiguity to the question whatsoever.  The poster didn't ask for help or advice.  You decided that instead of answering that question in a one-line helpful response, you came up with your almost completely unhelpful response.

You're comparing a second-hand, approx. 10 year old system with a brand-new one.  Yes, it's brand-new.  No-one has used it before, it is being sold as-new, with a warranty, no question there.  I would also expect a level of hardware and software support with the purchase, for the length of the warranty at least.

A PowerMac G4 is approximately ten years old.  You can only get one second-hand, no guarantee, and I would expect pretty much any general-purpose computer of that age to be a bargain basement price because it is well past its sell-by date, there's no guarantee how long the hardware will last or what condition it is in now.  The current version of Apple's intended OS for this product will not work on it, so by that metric (as well as software support for MacOS), the product is obsolete.  I assume that it is technically possible to run AmigaOS on a PowerMac G4, but unless you mention that and the user in question is capable of doing that, it's not a lot of help is it?

Hardware availability?  If you can buy it, it's available, right?

Hardware performance - for relevant benchmarks, it depends largely on what the user wants to run.

Hardware quality - Have you measured this?  If so, how?  If not, why are you mentioning this?  Because if you're able to measure scientifically the quality of hardware, I'd really like to know.  Also, if such a test existed and worked as it is supposed to, I would be really surprised if a 10-year-old computer was shown to be in a fitter state of health than a brand-new one.

What features the OS has - if it does what the user wants it to do, what's the problem?  People buy this because they want to run AmigaOS.  There are other solutions which can run AmigaOS, but not many brand-new ones AFAIK.

The level of Amiga compatibility in the OS - repeat previous response.

Amiga standards - repeat previous response.

So, in your "helpful" response on the first page of this thread, how much of this did you convey?  Do you think that your initial response help the person asking the question to make a well-educated and informed decision?

To someone who wasn't able to recognise that was a PowerMac G4, that picture conveyed "An X1000 costs 30 PowerMacs".  Incredibly helpful.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: klx300r on April 02, 2012, 05:46:34 PM
Quote from: Piru;686549
..I know it's hard to accept that 5+ years old apple HW can beat your favorite, and is a lot cheaper, and is more easily available, and has better support and repair possibilities...

first off, see post no.3 & btw, grandma beat you to it this time:razz:

lastly & more importantly, pay attention now, I DON'T CARE that old apple hardware runs faster than my X1000 in it's current state or even when AmigaOS exploits all it's potential. I'm having fun with my X1000 and feel a sense of pride in helping test my favourite operating system and seeing it develop as time passes. I'm sure you feel the same about MOS right.

rather than trolling on every single OS4.x thread why not just start another thread bashing what ever the heck you want about OS4.x hardware/software?? this way like minded people can join in and, more importantly, people that actually want to read the thread in question can do so without being harrassed over & over again....I've been married for too long and get enough of that on a daily basis already;)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: fishy_fiz on April 02, 2012, 05:49:20 PM
@billyfish
Quote from: billyfish;686537
30 PowerMacs? As currency goes, it's a little bit cumbersome! :-)


Thanks, I enjoyed that. Funniest thing in the entire thread, and anyone who read the entire thread will appreciate the competition for laughs contained within :)

It's a scary day when *IM* marvelling at the stupidity and immaturity on display :)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Piru on April 02, 2012, 05:54:42 PM
Quote from: klx300r;686564
I DON'T CARE
Funny I was certain I could read you post
"even better please post it at the Apple recycling website."

Certainly I have nothing against anyone spending their hard earned money as they see fit. Even if it's something as silly as a $3200 custom built HW with no support after couple of years. If you can't stand me pointing out how silly it is, please ignore me or something.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: takemehomegrandma on April 02, 2012, 05:58:05 PM
Quote from: billyfish;686547
why do you care so much about something that you clearly have no intention of buying


I'm providing a critical view in a community where criticism aren't allowed, consumer awareness about better alternatives in a community with a long tradition of shifting semi-functional products to gullible trade mark followers at an overprice, and rational thinking in a community where all rationality and logic seemingly left over a decade ago. "The usual suspects" always come moaning abou this, as we see in this thread as well.

Let's look at the "provocative" picture again, that made some of them cough their Kool-Aid all over their Boing-Ball branded keyboard from Amigakit:

(http://farm8.staticflickr.com/7059/6892045166_eae890172c_b.jpg)

What provokes them aren't the fact that this is roughly how many (depending on your search abilities) PPC NG computers you can get for *the same* amount of money as one single A1X1K system. No, what provokes them is the fact that someone has the nerve to actually point this out!

Is the A1X1K really better and faster? Not really, at least not by a great deal, it's roughly the same. To *really* illustrate the madness: For $3,000 (which is an obscene, almost provoking, amount of money for a computer in itself), you can actually get *30* fully working systems, each about on par with the A1X1K. You can use one, keep a second one for spare parts or whatever, and *give away* 28 machines (twenty-eight!) to developers or 68k users that may be curious to take the "NG Step". TWENTY-EIGHT people could have been provided a NG machine, after you have set up one (and having a spare), all at roughly the same speed as the A1X1K.

Another example - There was a community initiated effort (bounty on power2people collecting money for it) of involving bPlan (maker of Pegasos and other high-quality HW) to design a new desktop motherboard based on the 8610, one of the (if not *the*) fastest G4's ever made. It was a multi-step bounty, with a money sum that seemed incredibly high for a bounty system. But it would have resulted in a very capable and totally open source and community owned design, and it would have had a sponsored development program with free HW as well (as we have seen from other Genesi/bPlan HW launches). The irony is that all this would have taken was some 20-30 buyers of the A1X1K placing their money towards that instead. That's how excessively obscenely über-expensive the whole A1X1K deal is, without bringing much to the table beyond what a PowerMac/MacMini/PowerBook can do.

Billyfish, I will keep enlighten the world about things like this, about the alternatives you can choose instead. Don't like this? Well, too bad...
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: klx300r on April 02, 2012, 06:07:19 PM
Quote from: Piru;686567
..Certainly I have nothing against anyone spending their hard earned money as they see fit. Even if it's something as silly as a $3200 custom built HW with no support after couple of years. If you can't stand me pointing out how silly it is, please ignore me or something.

dude I love your persistence:crazy: listen I've got to get back to work so I'm punching the clock on this one (think Looney Tunes-sheep dog & coyote if that reference works in Finland).

see you in the next OS4.x thread
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: mikeymike on April 02, 2012, 06:17:31 PM
Quote from: takemehomegrandma;686568
I'm providing a critical view in a community where
criticism aren't allowed


LOL, it's like Burma here isn't it.  However do you manage to keep up your heroic efforts and spirits in the face of all this oppression.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: antikk on April 02, 2012, 06:21:54 PM
And how would you know? Always nioce to hear from the experts.

Quote from: Piru;686549
and has better support and repair possibilities...
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Piru on April 02, 2012, 06:22:13 PM
@mikeymike
Quote
LOL, it's like Burma here isn't it.
Bad analogy there I'd say.

It is quite hard to avoid the impression that certain parties should be considered avoid any and all criticism.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: antikk on April 02, 2012, 06:22:58 PM
@grandma

But what has a powermac to do with the xx1000?
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Piru on April 02, 2012, 06:24:49 PM
Quote from: antikk;686575
And how would you know? Always nioce to hear from the experts.
http://lmgtfy.com/?q=apple+powerpc+repair

Now try to get your X1000 repaired 5+ years from now...
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: eliyahu on April 02, 2012, 06:27:26 PM
Quote from: mikeymike;686572
LOL, it's like Burma here isn't it.  However do you manage to keep up your heroic efforts and spirits in the face of all this oppression.
i know, i know. saint TMHG continues the good fight on behalf of all that is beautiful and noble in the world against the hoards of evil OS4 users. aren't we so fortunate to have the MOS team and their crusaders here to show us the light? :rolleyes:

fight on, dear martyrs, fight on! for those who do not see the light must be fought on their own ground. never give in! never surrender! we need your enlightenment, your brilliant guidance, on every OS4 thread, o acolytes of the butterfly! only you can divine how when people talk about anything OS4-related on this site, what they really want is to talk about how MOS is superior! they must be shown the path and the glory! MOS FTW!!!!!!!!!!! :lol:

-- eliyahu
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: antikk on April 02, 2012, 06:30:04 PM
Sure, i'll do that.

Quote from: Piru;686578
http://lmgtfy.com/?q=apple+powerpc+repair

Now try to get your X1000 repaired 5+ years from now...
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: eliyahu on April 02, 2012, 06:31:31 PM
Quote from: Piru;686578
http://lmgtfy.com/?q=apple+powerpc+repair

Now try to get your X1000 repaired 5+ years from now...
why, piru, i didn't realize your god-like abilities extended even so far as to divine the future! hail, hail, o all-seeing lord of the butterfly! we humbly submit to your superior wit and wisdom! :crazy:

-- eliyahu
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Piru on April 02, 2012, 06:33:58 PM
Quote from: eliyahu;686582
piru, i didn't realize abilities extended even so far as to divine the future

You don't need to be an Nostradamus incarnate to realize that computer with maybe 500 units sold will have way worse support than computer that sold millions.

Really.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Duce on April 02, 2012, 06:37:19 PM
Where are you getting your "20-30" buyers numbers from, TMHG?

I doubt the X1000 sold a boatload off the first production run, so they are likely indeed low - just curious who's ass you are pulling numbers out of this time.

To address the OP, in regards to registering interest.  I've always stated in no uncertain terms that I felt the prebuilt system idea was a detriment to the X1000 project.  I haven't bought a prebuilt PC in like 20 years, in fact I think the last one I bought was likely the PC that replaced my A4000.  Many others are in the same boat.  Many are hardware jockeys like me that want to build their own machines, people that simply do not buy prebuilts.  We like our own case picks.  We like our own HD, PSU, RAM, etc. choices and simply won't buy a prebuilt.  Ever.  Wintel or PPC, or anything in between.

Having a motherboard only option would not only lower the cost (face it, they *are* making a premium on the components - that's only basic business sense), but would have actually got me on the sign up sheet regarding pre-orders if the price on the mobo was acceptable.  Can't help but think a lot more people would have been interested if a bare mobo was available like the SAM boards - and yes, system builders are well aware of the risks of them killing boards if they build systems in a stupid fashion.

I was signed up on their email mailing list before it was announced that they would only be coming in prebuilt form.  I wouldn't have bought my SAM 440ep is a bare mobo option wasn't available.  While I can't say price isn't a factor, I was truly interested in the X1000 when I was going under the assumption I could throw it together with my own components.  Sadly them not offering that lost them a customer and a developer, as meager and niche as my coding efforts are (face it, no one is buying OS4 machines to run PPC native telnet BBS software on, lol).
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: eliyahu on April 02, 2012, 06:40:15 PM
Quote from: Piru;686583
You don't need to be an Nostradamus incarnate to realize that computer with maybe 500 units sold will have way worse support than computer that sold millions.

Really.
indeed. and how fortunate we have you to point that out and freely share your heavenly genius with us wayward folks who have yet to adopt the path. i so enjoy your astounding insights every time i read a thread even remotely related to OS4 or OS4 hardware platforms on this site. please, what other fascinating bits of badger-sputumly inconsequential MOS propaganda will you assail us with next? i can hardly wait!


-- eliyahu
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Piru on April 02, 2012, 06:42:09 PM
@eliyahu

I usually post facts with little sugar coating. Intolerable, I know. Often so much that I get to enjoy the puny attempts at snide remarks and poorly veiled insults.

If someone wants to provoke me they'll have to try much much harder.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: eliyahu on April 02, 2012, 06:44:25 PM
Quote from: Duce;686584
Where are you getting your "20-30" buyers numbers from, TMHG?

I doubt the X1000 sold a boatload off the first production run, so they are likely indeed low - just curious who's ass you are pulling numbers out of this time.
his. the source of most of his 'knowledge' of the other guys.

Quote
Having a motherboard only option would not only lower the cost (face it, they *are* making a premium on the components - that's only basic business sense), but would have actually got me on the sign up sheet regarding pre-orders if the price on the mobo was acceptable.  Can't help but think a lot more people would have been interested if a bare mobo was available like the SAM boards - and yes, system builders are well aware of the risks of them killing boards if they build systems in a stupid fashion.

I was signed up on their email mailing list before it was announced that they would only be coming in prebuilt form.  I wouldn't have bought my SAM 440ep is a bare mobo option wasn't available.  While I can't say price isn't a factor, I was truly interested in the X1000 when I was going under the assumption I could throw it together with my own components.  Sadly them not offering that lost them a customer and a developer, as meager and niche as my coding efforts are (face it, no one is buying OS4 machines to run PPC native telnet BBS software on, lol).
i have to agree with you, there. i really wish they'd offer just the board. of course i could have signed up to be a tester, but i don't really like the idea of paying for the privilege of testing someone else's product. usually it's the other way around.

and given the massive shipping charges customers see here in the US, offering just the board would save us substantial money just on that point alone. have you emailed matthew and/or trevor to see if they would make an exception for you?

-- eliyahu
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: eliyahu on April 02, 2012, 06:44:57 PM
Quote from: Piru;686586
@eliyahu

I usually post facts with little sugar coating. Intolerable, I know.
oh, come on. is that the best you can come up with? :lol:

-- eliyahu
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: fishy_fiz on April 02, 2012, 06:48:07 PM
Firstly, I have no interest in NG "amiga" options anymore. If I want a machine to deal with the modern world, I'll use a modern machine, simple as that (and I'll get it for cheaper than either OS4 or MOS' cost of entry). Now I say this so people are under no illusions as to my agenda. This said:

This is an amiga website. There's few outside eyes watching. People know what theyre buying into, they know the stories, they know prices/pros/cons.

Do all the clowns that keep posting the same **** over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over (yes, its excessive to type the same thing so often, but some people think this is normal) is enlightening anyone? Do they think theyre providing any revalations? Are they really so stupid as to think people dont see right through any feeble attempts to cover thier real agenda? People who are interested in something arent going to be swayed by people so transparent they irritate even those with no interest. Want to promote your system of choice? Great, but these negative tactics lose any value pretty quickly, to a point that any interest someone originally had in the product promoted by those using negative tactics also fades pretty quickly.

Personally I love my a1200 still. It cost me a pretty penny to upgrade it to a point its on par with a mac or pc Id have thown away 15 years ago, but guess what? I dont give a ****, it's my hobby and I enjoy it. No amount ot negativity from strangers who by now sound either like turrets sufferers stuck on a groove, or mentally challenged will change that.

This isnt to say I dont find some benchmarks interesting, I do, but there's only so many times a person can find a tenuous segue and repeat the same thing before they make people like me lose interest (someone who was previously interested in all amiga options until the community changed his mind with all the bull****(and make no mistake this isnt just one camp either)).

So no, youre not "informing people", youre doing damage and making the amiga scene appear as screwed up as it really is.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: spirantho on April 02, 2012, 06:52:32 PM
What I really love is the fact that the PowerMacs in question are FAR slower than a cheap bargain basement x86 box, which can run AROS.
So what if 30 Power Macs can be bought for one X1000? You can get a much faster x86 for the same price, and AROS has just as much to do with AmigaOS 4 as MorphOS does - i.e. none at all.

So if you're going to buy an NG system and don't want to buy an X1000, then get an x86 box and run AROS. But if you want to run AmigaOS 4, then it can't be a PowerMac so there's no point whatsoever mentioning it.

Stupid thing is that this MorphOS evangelism every time OS4 is mentioned has done far more damage to the MOS reputation than both AROS and AmigaOS put together.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: eliyahu on April 02, 2012, 06:52:56 PM
@fishy_fiz

that's probably the best reply so far. honestly, if i had found this site before i purchased my SAM and entered the 'amiga community' a couple of years back, i wouldn't have bothered. stuff like this really is a turn-off. i need to be careful i don't start getting sucked into the fighting like this again.

@thread

let's just get back on topic, shall we? i'll go ahead and start by unilaterally ceasing fire. :o

-- eliyahu
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: matt3k on April 02, 2012, 06:57:23 PM
As I have already said...

http://www.amiga.org/forums/showpost.php?p=669526&postcount=179
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Derfs on April 02, 2012, 06:57:52 PM
@takemehomegrandma
Quote
The irony is that all this would have taken was some 20-30 buyers of the A1X1K placing their money towards that instead.


math is not your strong suit I take it. that would be the amount to design it. thats it.

I think you forgot that they would then have to pay more to actually purchase it, and that would be very expensive for a limited run, but your impression of "the sky is falling" doesnt work well with the facts.

tmhg, you are the equivalent of the crazy religious people i see in town, annoying me by trying to get me to join their religion, whilst im just happy as i am. you are speaking to people like they are idiots that dont know any better, and that is just sad you feel the need to treat people like that, when they can make up their own minds.

a cppc is more expensive than a powermac, and less powerfull, why are you not showing us classic owners the correct way to think?
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Derfs on April 02, 2012, 07:02:56 PM
Quote from: fishy_fiz;686591
*snip*

So no, youre not "informing people", youre doing damage and making the amiga scene appear as screwed up as it really is.


+1, like, RT etc
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: fishy_fiz on April 02, 2012, 07:11:19 PM
Quote from: matt3k;686598
As I have already said...

http://www.amiga.org/forums/showpost.php?p=669526&postcount=179


[country hick accent]
We dont want none o' your kind 'round here. We calls 'em "logicals" an' they aint fit in with us NG ameegans
[/country hick accent]

translation:
That makes way too much sense for this place :)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Fats on April 02, 2012, 07:12:24 PM
Quote from: Piru;686576
@mikeymike

It is quite hard to avoid the impression that certain parties should be considered avoid any and all criticism.


I do have more the impression that the sole existence of some people is to criticize anything related to OS4.
But then I am a weird person.

Staf.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: itix on April 02, 2012, 07:34:17 PM
Quote from: billyfish;686537
The relevant part was actually "Also please keep in mind most of the X1000 system is still unoptimized." My point is, as with any software, when it's in beta, it's not generally going to be running at the same speed as in its final polished state.

Your point being?

Today A1X1K costs X dollars and scores Y in benchmarks. What it costs in the future and how fast it performs in the future are just useless. My MorphOS could be faster than anything else in the future when it is running on future with future optimisations but it could be just the sun explodes tomorrow.

Instead of playing usual pissing contest why not just say what it costs, what it does and that is it? You dont have to care what Mac costs of what MorphOS does. TMHGM didnt even mention MorphOS in his post. So please stop your witch hunt and learn to read.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: billyfish on April 02, 2012, 07:40:21 PM
Quote from: Piru;686549
I'll rather post it to "comparing MorphOS on quad core G5 vs AmigaOS 4 on dual core X1000" thread which would make as much sense, i.e. none.


I'm glad that we agree that the benchmark comparison has a sense rating of none as I explain below...

Quote
I know it's hard to accept that 5+ years old apple HW can beat your favorite, and is a lot cheaper, and is more easily available, and has better support and repair possibilities...


Piru, the X1000 software is still unoptimised. You know as well as I do that the benchmark comparisons aren't worth the pixels they're drawn with if you're comparing a debug-type build with an optimised one.

[OFF TOPIC]
I once built a large scale molecular simulation and after running and ananlysing it, managed to get a 900% increase, by changing all the distance comparisons to work in squared distances rather than Euclidean. I.e. getting rid of sqrt () from getting the distance from A to B worked wonders.
[/OFF TOPIC]

My point being compiler support and algorithm optimisation can make *HUGE* differences and given that they've said that it's currently unoptimised means that there is a large scope for improvement.


I'd suggest that a more accurate representation *as the software stands at the minute* would be

1. Code running on a single core on the PowerMacs is probably slightly quicker a single core of the X1000.

2. The memory access speeds on the X1000 are much faster than on the PowerMac.

3. The graphics card capabilities of the x1000 are much ahead of the Mac Mini.

4. All these are subject to change as OS4 and MorphOS code gets more optimised for these systems.

Would you agree with this?
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: itix on April 02, 2012, 07:41:57 PM
Quote from: Fats;686604
I do have more the impression that the sole existence of some people is to criticize anything related to OS4.
But then I am a weird person.


Didnt you piss off OS4 core developers on that Timberwolf thread at AWN...?

But really, what is wrong with some people. Someone asks how much AmigaOne costs and TMHGM replies with it costs as much as 30 used PowerMacs. Then some usual suspects go berserk but dont bother to tell how much it really costs.

To me it seems that some people are applying double standards here.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: spirantho on April 02, 2012, 07:51:37 PM
The point is that measuring in PowerMacs is pointless. You may as well say it costs 7,000 grapefruit - a grapefruit can run OS4 just as well as a Powermac, after all.

The problem is that every time - and I mean every time - someone mentions OS4, the thread gets derailed by the same people with the same unrelated posts.

We know MOS runs on Powermacs. We get that.
We also get that the X1000 costs a lot more than 10-year-old Powermacs. We get that too.
We also get that the X1000 runs AmigaOS 4 which Powermacs don't.

But do the MOS people get the fact that some people want to run AmigaOS 4 and not MOS?

MorphOS is a great piece of work, but it doesn't belong in a thread about the X1000 - at all.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Piru on April 02, 2012, 07:54:45 PM
Quote from: spirantho;686618
MorphOS is a great piece of work, but it doesn't belong in a thread about the X1000 - at all.

Why not?
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: billyfish on April 02, 2012, 08:00:22 PM
Quote from: takemehomegrandma;686568
I'm providing a critical view in a community where criticism aren't allowed, consumer awareness about better alternatives in a community with a long tradition of shifting semi-functional products to gullible trade mark followers at an overprice, and rational thinking in a community where all rationality and logic seemingly left over a decade ago. "The usual suspects" always come moaning abou this, as we see in this thread as well.

Let's look at the "provocative" picture again, that made some of them cough their Kool-Aid all over their Boing-Ball branded keyboard from Amigakit:


provocative, as in titillating? I can't say an orgy with 30 power macs really does it for me :-)

Quote

What provokes them aren't the fact that this is roughly how many (depending on your search abilities) PPC NG computers you can get for *the same* amount of money as one single A1X1K system. No, what provokes them is the fact that someone has the nerve to actually point this out!


WTF?!? Do you genuinely believe that criticism, constructive or otherwise, isn't allowed isn't allowed on this forum???

Quote

Billyfish, I will keep enlighten the world about things like this, about the alternatives you can choose instead. Don't like this? Well, too bad...


But you bang on about it in every single os4-related thread. Do you genuinely think you become more persuasive by repeating something over and over again? I absolutely concede that there's a very different price point between an x1000 and a morphos-enabled mac. You mention the alternatives you can choose instead, the point is if someone *still* chooses to get the X1000, that's their prerogative. Why it bothers you so much is just plain bonkers to me. In the same way I can't imagine sitting here fuming that somebody has decided to buy 5 country and western albums even though I said I didn't like that music, HOW DARED THEY!! ;-)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: itix on April 02, 2012, 08:02:11 PM
Quote from: spirantho;686618
The point is that measuring in PowerMacs is pointless. You may as well say it costs 7,000 grapefruit - a grapefruit can run OS4 just as well as a Powermac, after all.

If I say it costs 3000 dollars are you going to argue dollars cant run OS4?

Quote
The problem is that every time - and I mean every time - someone mentions OS4, the thread gets derailed by the same people with the same unrelated posts.

This thread started derailing right after post number 2. Wonder who were they?

Quote
We know MOS runs on Powermacs. We get that.

Thank you repeating it again. We know. drHirudo told us.

Quote
We also get that the X1000 costs a lot more than 10-year-old Powermacs. We get that too.

How much it costs? Is it really so difficult to answer it? Is it so difficult that after 10 offtopic posts including Amiga.org moderator I had to tell how much it costs?

Quote
We also get that the X1000 runs AmigaOS 4 which Powermacs don't.

That is great. I am not going to buy PowerMac nor AmigaOne.

Quote
But do the MOS people get the fact that some people want to run AmigaOS 4 and not MOS?

MorphOS is a great piece of work, but it doesn't belong in a thread about the X1000 - at all.

None of my business. AmigaKit is selling and advertising AmigaOne here. Someone asks what it does, what it costs, whatever and we answer. Yup, tmhgm loves MorphOS, is evangelising here but you dont have to feel so insecure whenever MorphOS is mentioned on this site. Maybe annoying to you sometimes but the best counter argument is facts.

I know I would write to Commodore USA threads what you never would do.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: billyfish on April 02, 2012, 08:03:54 PM
Quote from: fishy_fiz;686566
@billyfish


Thanks, I enjoyed that. Funniest thing in the entire thread, and anyone who read the entire thread will appreciate the competition for laughs contained within :)

It's a scary day when *IM* marvelling at the stupidity and immaturity on display :)


Thank you! /me takes a bow :-)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: takemehomegrandma on April 02, 2012, 08:12:35 PM
Quote from: Duce;686584
Where are you getting your "20-30" buyers numbers from, TMHG?


20 is the bounty divided by $3,000 (I wrote 30 to cover all eventualities since I can't remember whether the bounty was in Euro or Dollars, or the exact bounty target for that matter).
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: billyfish on April 02, 2012, 08:29:22 PM
Quote from: Duce;686584

Having a motherboard only option would not only lower the cost (face it, they *are* making a premium on the components - that's only basic business sense), but would have actually got me on the sign up sheet regarding pre-orders if the price on the mobo was acceptable.  


This is an interesting point, I agree that having a motherboard-only option would be a good idea. Hypothetically speaking, given the price for the pre-built system, what price would the motherboard need to be approximately for you to want to go for it? I wonder if there were enough people of a similar view to you whether Trevor and co might be tempted to offer that option.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: jorkany on April 02, 2012, 08:32:48 PM
Quote from: itix;686609
Instead of playing usual pissing contest why not just say what it costs, what it does and that is it? You dont have to care what Mac costs of what MorphOS does. TMHGM didnt even mention MorphOS in his post. So please stop your witch hunt and learn to read.


itix brings up a very valid and on-topic point here about the costs. How can one "register  interest" when vital information is not available? How is registering interest even useful as a measuring stick when there's missing information that when revealed later could reduce interest? What's the big secret now anyway, there's already been one run. The whole thing is just silly!
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: drHirudo on April 02, 2012, 08:35:57 PM
Quote from: itix;686623
None of my business. AmigaKit is selling and advertising AmigaOne here. Someone asks what it does, what it costs, whatever and we answer. Yup, tmhgm loves MorphOS, is evangelising here but you dont have to feel so insecure whenever MorphOS is mentioned on this site. Maybe annoying to you sometimes but the best counter argument is facts.


Oh, well, I get it now. The fact that there are still businesses in Amiga land that SELL something, annoys the MOS fanboys, because there is not a single business left, dealing with the amateur wanna-be OS called MOS. So they feel the need to pollute every thread and raise their arguments about the PowerMacs, how they are fast, reliable, cheap, easy to replace and so on.

Well, my Sony Vaio can emulate classic Amiga much better and more faster than the Minimig, but I don't post in Minimig related threads about that fact.

The same for the Turbo Chameleon 64 (http://www.vesalia.de/e_chameleon.htm). For the price it costs you can buy complete machine with monitor and have money left for beer. But I don't post in Chameleon related threads either.

The Minimig and the Chameleon are nice little devices that do well what they are built for. Even if relatively expensive, they are cool, they are excellent purchases for the people who are enjoying their hobby and that is more important, than buying 30 crap macs that you will not find a good use for.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: takemehomegrandma on April 02, 2012, 08:46:50 PM
Quote from: fishy_fiz;686591
So no, youre not "informing people", youre doing damage and making the amiga scene appear as screwed up as it really is.


I simply pointed out the obvious lunacy in trying to shift 2007 level HW at $3,000 a piece (by showing what you can get as an alternative), and then you get upset with *me* for making things "look crazy", instead of being upset by the craziness itself! :crazy: Yeah...  :lol:

Buying ONE A1X1K for $3,000, or buying THIRTY computers of roughly A1X1K performance for the same amount of money, or buying one computer at 1/30th of the cost — It's a free world and people with no respect for moneys value are free to make a $3,000 bonfire if they think it's a smart thing to do (I don't however, and in this free world I reserve the right to suggest to them how the money could be better spent). Don't blame *me* for "making the amiga scene appear as screwed up as it really is", I was merely pointing out alternatives to $3,000 bonfires. Everyone with a brain sober enough from Kool-Aid will see the screwed up situation in the first option (or even the first *two* options), and only those who don't can possibly be "provoked" by my picture anyway...
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: itix on April 02, 2012, 08:48:33 PM
@drHirudo

Thank you for registering your interest for AmigaOne X1000.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Iggy on April 02, 2012, 08:53:14 PM
Quote from: drHirudo;686633
O...amateur wanna-be OS called MOS...

We get it Dr. Troll , you don't like Macs and MorphOS.
Its funny, as a MorphOS user I can still exchange pleasant messages with OS4 developer Steve Solie, but I have read verbal diarrhea like this from trolls like you.
As we still have plenty of Pegasos machines available on the used market and have the advantage of being able to use low cost hardware from Apple I'm not particularly worried about not having new hardware.
In fact in some benchmarks, my ten year old Powermac outperforms an X1000.
In others its not far behind.

And if I did purchase an X1000, I'd have a much more even handed response to both camps then you would appear to have.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Piru on April 02, 2012, 09:05:56 PM
Quote from: billyfish;686610
the X1000 software is still unoptimised.
This claim keeps resurfacing, but I haven't seen any valid data to back this up. I have a feeling this is the same old claim that has always been thrown around when MorphOS has beaten AmigaOS4. If you follow this line of reasoning AmigaOS4 is still unoptimized, not only X1000 but classics, AmigaONE GE/XE/Micro, Sam440 and Sam460, too.

Quote
I'd suggest that a more accurate representation *as the software stands at the minute* would be

1. Code running on a single core on the PowerMacs is probably slightly quicker a single core of the X1000.
Depends on the speed of the PowerMac CPU of course.

Quote
2. The memory access speeds on the X1000 are much faster than on the PowerMac.
This is true.

Quote
3. The graphics card capabilities of the x1000 are much ahead of the Mac Mini.
This makes little practical difference as there are no 3D drivers for the new cards. MorphOS is massively ahead in 3D.

Quote
4. All these are subject to change as OS4 and MorphOS code gets more optimised for these systems.
I don't see much performance improvements coming from code optimizations at this point, at least for MorphOS. MorphOS has been fairly optimal for years.

Now, it might be that OS4 is still lagging behind in numerous ways but considering it has been way over 10 years now I can't see how it would change anytime soon.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: drHirudo on April 02, 2012, 09:08:02 PM
Quote from: Iggy;686640
you don't like Macs and MorphOS.

Wrong. I have a Mac and I want it to be able to run MOS. It's not my fault that MOS is not available for PowerBooks. MacOS X runs on it.
Quote

Its funny, as a MorphOS user I can still exchange pleasant messages with OS4 developer Steve Solie,

I exchange messages with devepers for MOS, AmigaOS 4, IOS, VIC-20 etc... They have nothing against me for using AmigaOS 4, neither do I have anything against them for not using AmigaOS 4.
Quote
As we still have plenty of Pegasos machines available on the used market and have the advantage of being able to use low cost hardware from Apple I'm not particularly worried about not having new hardware.

Well, I prefer new hardware over old. I can not replace my old Mac, but on other hand I replaced my Dell Laptop with Sony laptop, because the Dell began overheating and freezing. Now I can sport on i7-2670QM that beats every PowerMac available, performance-wise. But that's not stopping me working on my AmigaOne. One month ago I had trouble with my microAmiga though. I had to replace the battery, after seven years of usage :(
Quote
In fact in some benchmarks, my ten year old Powermac outperforms an X1000.
In others its not far behind.

In fact my AmigaOne outperforms the Turbo Chameleon 64. Your point being?
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: billyfish on April 02, 2012, 09:33:22 PM
Quote from: Piru;686641
This claim keeps resurfacing, but I haven't seen any valid data to back this up.


I'm going by Steve Solie's comment on the Hyperion blog. Since neither you nor I have access to the OS4 code, I see no reason not to take him at his word.


Quote

This makes little practical difference as there are no 3D drivers for the new cards. MorphOS is massively ahead in 3D.


I disagree on this being of little practical difference since this is currently being worked on by Hans de Ruiter and the Friedens on the OpenGL implementation means we'll see a leap in performance when this comes into play.

Quote

I don't see much performance improvements coming from code optimizations at this point, at least for MorphOS. MorphOS has been fairly optimal for years.

Now, it might be that OS4 is still lagging behind in numerous ways but considering it has been way over 10 years now I can't see how it would change anytime soon.


On this I'll agree that MorphOS appears to be more optimised but I disagree that OS4 can't catch up. I think one of the reasons that OS4 took longer to get going is that prior to the SAMs being released, OS4 was limited to cyberstorm boards, whereas MorphOS had made the leap to the PPC macs. I think that there's definitely the potential for OS4 on the X1000 to take up some of this slack. I guess time will tell which one of us has the less murky crystal ball.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Sandman on April 02, 2012, 09:47:49 PM
Hopefully I am not going to far off thread here.  

As I never plan to buy an X1000 (although I have almost every other model amiga ever made) and have not really done any homework on it, I still have one question.

Exactly what software is available for this platform only.  Is the majority just home-brews and ports of stuff from other OS'es?  That would be the real make-or-break for me.  I am not interested in the "phoenix shall rise from the ashes" nostalgia, I have my classics for that (and no, that bird is dead and ain't coming back).

Even if I could buy the best new version of an out-of-production rare classic car, motorcycle, whatever, etc. I would not be interested if I couldn't get fuel to have it even function as well as my neighbor's moped.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Piru on April 02, 2012, 09:48:51 PM
Quote from: billyfish;686651
I'm going by Steve Solie's comment on the Hyperion blog.

Can you link to it? I find it interesting that PA-6T would require specific optimizations, though.

Quote
I disagree on this being of little practical difference since this is currently being worked on by Hans de Ruiter and the Friedens on the OpenGL implementation means we'll see a leap in performance when this comes into play.

It's not like MorphOS has been standing still regarding 3D either, but I assumed "accurate representation *as the software stands at the minute*". So we'll consider "future tech" after all?

Quote
On this I'll agree that MorphOS appears to be more optimised but I disagree that OS4 can't catch up. I think one of the reasons that OS4 took longer to get going is that prior to the SAMs being released, OS4 was limited to cyberstorm boards, whereas MorphOS had made the leap to the PPC macs.

I'd say it's rather the opposite. Most of the MorphOS optimizations were already done by the time MorphOS was ported to Mac mini. Bulk of the work was done on the slower systems where the difference in optimization could be easily felt in practice.

Quote
I think that there's definitely the potential for OS4 on the X1000 to take up some of this slack.

I think it's rather the opposite that might happen. With all the raw CPU crunch and especially fast memory bus around it is IMHO more likely that basic optimizations are not done because performance is already adequate with less optimal code. Similar progression has happened with Linux for instance where for instance reliance on large CPU caches and fast memory bus has severely hurt performance on low end systems.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Iggy on April 02, 2012, 10:16:02 PM
Quote from: Piru;686620
Why not?

Absolutely Piru!
Why not?!

I have a Powermac running MorphOS but I've registered with Amigakit to receive notice when this second batch is ready.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: number6 on April 02, 2012, 10:18:56 PM
Quote from: Piru;686656
Can you link to it? I find it interesting that PA-6T would require specific optimizations, though.



3rd paragraph (http://blog.hyperion-entertainment.biz/?p=580)

#6
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Iggy on April 02, 2012, 10:19:39 PM
Quote from: drHirudo;686642
In fact my AmigaOne outperforms the Turbo Chameleon 64. Your point being?

Useful information and not surprising as a PPC is considerably more powerful then an FPGA.

Nice to see you interacting civilly Doc.

And MorphOS support for Powerbooks should be available in about two weeks. ;)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Methuselas on April 02, 2012, 10:37:17 PM
LOL! Did I *REALLY* just read this entire thread??!????


Pssh.  XD

:roflmao:
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Darrin on April 02, 2012, 10:52:43 PM
Quote from: Piru;686583
You don't need to be an Nostradamus incarnate to realize that computer with maybe 500 units sold will have way worse support than computer that sold millions.

Really.


Yeah, every time I walk down the highstreet I'm tripping over Commodore 64 service centers at every corner.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Piru on April 02, 2012, 11:02:10 PM
Quote from: Darrin;686664
Yeah, every time I walk down the highstreet I'm tripping over Commodore 64 service centers at every corner.
You're much more likely to find support, repair, spare parts and new hardware devices (and complete reimplementation in FPGA!) for Commodore 64 than Jupiter ACE.

Q.E.D
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Kesa on April 02, 2012, 11:10:57 PM
Quote from: Piru;686549
I'll rather post it to "comparing MorphOS on quad core G5 vs AmigaOS 4 on dual core X1000" thread which would make as much sense, i.e. none.


I know it's hard to accept that 5+ years old apple HW can beat your favorite, and is a lot cheaper, and is more easily available, and has better support and repair possibilities...

Piru, i agree with this completely. But it's still an apple therefore it is crap. I use Mos on a MacMini and i can't stand the thing...
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Rob on April 02, 2012, 11:16:09 PM
Quote from: Piru;686620
Quote:
Quote
Originally Posted by spirantho  
MorphOS is a great piece of work, but it doesn't belong in a thread about the X1000 - at all.

Why not?


Presumably because you, Ralph and the others behind MorphOS are not interested in porting it to the X1000.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: billyfish on April 02, 2012, 11:18:02 PM
Quote
It's not like MorphOS has been standing still regarding 3D either, but I assumed "accurate representation *as the software stands at the minute*". So we'll consider "future tech" after all?


Fair point, my fourth point was more future looking.

Quote

I'd say it's rather the opposite. Most of the MorphOS optimizations were already done by the time MorphOS was ported to Mac mini. Bulk of the work was done on the slower systems where the difference in optimization could be easily felt in practice.

I think it's rather the opposite that might happen. With all the raw CPU crunch and especially fast memory bus around it is IMHO more likely that basic optimizations are not done because performance is already adequate with less optimal code. Similar progression has happened with Linux for instance where for instance reliance on large CPU caches and fast memory bus has severely hurt performance on low end systems.


I see where you're coming from but I can give you another context. When I had a piece of software that took about an hour to compile on my 1200, it made testing, changing, debugging and optimising the code so much slower. Moving on to compiling it on my pc brought the compilation time down to about a couple of minutes. So whereas I could maybe build the project 4-5 times in a day previously, on my pc I could be way more productive. My desire to optimise the code remained exactly the same (I think most developers brought up on Amigas have a similar urge) and the massive increase in productivity meant I could do this without aging in front of a slow moving make process!

The point is the faster your development systems is, the more productive you can be. You can still test the software on a slower system in terms of finding optimistations.

The other side of optimisation are things like being able to utilise software that takes advantage of the extra system resources to hand, mpi and fftw spring to mind.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: takemehomegrandma on April 02, 2012, 11:33:13 PM
Quote from: Kesa;686669
Piru, i agree with this completely. But it's still an apple therefore it is crap. I use Mos on a MacMini and i can't stand the thing...


The Mac Mini is just slightly bigger than an Efika in a case (or slightly bigger than a CD, meaning *tiny*!), it's virtually noiseless, it has a built-in optical device etc, perfectly adequate graphics, it's way more powerful than any AmigaOne from Eyetech, any Pegasos, any Sam 440 or Sam 460 (meaning, it's much more powerful than anything that any "NG" folks traditionally has had to live with during the last decade), it's very cheap, it runs MorphOS very nicely (it plays x264 720p HD streams in SW), and you "can't stand the thing" because... it was *originally* made by Apple (even though you don't use MacOS on it now)? I'm curious, surely there must be some other reasons, or are you really *that* irrational?
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: kolla on April 03, 2012, 12:03:37 AM
Why all this bickering about 3D? I can't think of anything 3D I would want to do on either OS4 or MorphOS. Ditto for video.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Kesa on April 03, 2012, 12:12:54 AM
Quote from: takemehomegrandma;686676
The Mac Mini is just slightly bigger than an Efika in a case (or slightly bigger than a CD, meaning *tiny*!), it's virtually noiseless, it has a built-in optical device etc, perfectly adequate graphics, it's way more powerful than any AmigaOne from Eyetech, any Pegasos, any Sam 440 or Sam 460 (meaning, it's much more powerful than anything that any "NG" folks traditionally has had to live with during the last decade), it's very cheap, it runs MorphOS very nicely (it plays x264 720p HD streams in SW), and you "can't stand the thing" because... it was *originally* made by Apple (even though you don't use MacOS on it now)? I'm curious, surely there must be some other reasons, or are you really *that* irrational?

Don't forget about i (eye) pollution! Everytime i look at the thing i want to puke! Also the sound is crap from the 3.5mm output because of interference and leopard is as slow as a GIANT snail. It is also noisy because of that stupid optical drive.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: takemehomegrandma on April 03, 2012, 12:30:47 AM
Quote from: Kesa;686691
Don't forget about i (eye) pollution! Everytime i look at the thing i want to puke!

That's a matter of opinion I guess. When it comes to the Mini's design, my biggest (and only) grudge against it, is that the power button is in the back. I usually like to have a power button and a reset button both on front. But that's a minor thing anyway, and otherwise I find the Mini to be quite beautiful, with clean lines, a nice set of colors, etc. I think it's a perfect design (or had been if the power button hadn't been in the back)! :)

Quote
Also the sound is crap from the 3.5mm output because of interference

Sound could be better, I agree. It works fine, but could definitely be of a bit higher quality.

Quote
and leopard is as slow as a GIANT snail. It is also noisy because of that stupid optical drive.

You should really use Tiger on the Mini. And eject the disk when you are not using it... ;)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: bbond007 on April 03, 2012, 12:52:11 AM
Quote from: Kesa;686691
Don't forget about i (eye) pollution! Everytime i look at the thing i want to puke! Also the sound is crap from the 3.5mm output because of interference and leopard is as slow as a GIANT snail. It is also noisy because of that stupid optical drive.


I'd agree with most of that. Except I have never had an issue with the optical drive. I bought mine new.... I had a g3 ibook that i sold before buying the mini(so i did have soemthign to compare it to)... but that minig4  computer has the worst quality VGA output i have ever seen. I'm not the only one that has that issue. I was so disappointing  when I bought that thing. I would imagine that had to fix that in later models. And core duo macbook, unreliable, flaky and finally developed a few pixel wide line down the screen after seen very little actual travel.

my iphones have all been good, but the computers... not...
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: klx300r on April 03, 2012, 01:02:40 AM
ya great now to top it off this thread has gone to discussing apple products:quickdraw:
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: vox on April 03, 2012, 01:07:38 AM
Quote from: takemehomegrandma;686545
Why this über-sensitiveness about topics all the sudden? Judging by your über-strict views on topic-discipline, only post #2 was on topic (since it was Darrin "Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000",


All true, incl. benchmarks, but as we all know X1000 performance might really improve by new OS version, better Nemo board drivers and using second core. That is quite potential. And I am sure most of buyers are making informed decision knowing what they are getting now.

It would be way better if we had oportunity to use MorphOS 3.x on SAMs and X1000 and figure the difference on new hardware already purchased. That is way better then fighting it just on machine vs machine performance ratios.
As well as it would be great to have AmigaOS for PPC Macs which are not junk at all.

To my knowledge A1X1k is the only desktop computer to use PA Semi, which is unique, no matter how old the CPU is. Correct me if I am wrong.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: vox on April 03, 2012, 01:22:52 AM
Quote
Buying ONE A1X1K for $3,000, or buying THIRTY computers of roughly A1X1K performance for the same amount of money, or buying one computer .


No one is buying 30 computers, but since you are trying to equalize the worth please include 200 eur software licences to each Mac (OS 4.1.5 and 4.2 licence) or at least MorphOS licence per computer. Then you will get to more realistic 10-20 machines. But even that is not the point, just like with past AmigaOne and Pegasos boards, new PPC boards are expensive and come rarely. Enjoy the moment.

If you really think of comparing it with PPC MacMinis, take into account X1000 has dual core CPU that is yet to be used, much faster RAM, R700 video chip with a ton of VRAM, much more and is quite expandable board, especially when onboard drivers will be done. Board also supports 8GB RAM I believe, so might drive OS4 to brake its own limits in many, many ways (from RAM barreir, SMP, XMOS support, RadeonHD drivers ...). Hell, even supporting AMD bridge chip and RadeonHD is step forward some future AMD Fusion port :-)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Iggy on April 03, 2012, 01:58:09 AM
Quote from: klx300r;686699
ya great now to top it off this thread has gone to discussing apple products:quickdraw:

I don't mind discussing Apple products, but OSX I mean come on I don't even have that installed on my system.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: AmigaNG on April 03, 2012, 08:53:31 AM
Quote from: Piru;686567

Certainly I have nothing against anyone spending their hard earned money as they see fit. Even if it's something as silly as a $3200 custom built HW with no support after couple of years. If you can't stand me pointing out how silly it is, please ignore me or something.


Don't worry already have and enjoying my AmigaOne X1000 system.

as for costs, I think the cheapest you could get the system the first time around was around £2000 with taxs and delivery, this is no cheap hobby, the price nearly put me off it, but it's something I wanted for a while, it's not for everyone and if you really want a cheap Amiga ng type of experices then I would personally recommend getting an old pc and installing Aros on it, not a PowerMac.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: takemehomegrandma on April 03, 2012, 09:20:03 AM
Quote from: vox;686705
take into account X1000 has dual core CPU that is yet to be used, much faster RAM, R700 video chip with a ton of VRAM, much more and is quite expandable board, especially when onboard drivers will be done. Board also supports 8GB RAM I believe, so might drive OS4 to brake its own limits in many, many ways (from RAM barreir, SMP, XMOS support, RadeonHD drivers ...)


Yeah, it's always this "is yet to be used", "might", "future", yada, yada. Anyone knowing Hyperion, should really know by now that they love to sell unhatched chickens with great promises, long before the chickens are hatched. Sometimes it turns out in the end that the eggs never was laid, and never will be. Was the Micro A1 GX ever sorted out/fully supported? The driver situation on the Sam? Back in 2009, when the performance of OS4 and MorphOS 2.3 was compared on exactly the same HW (http://obligement.free.fr/articles/amigaos41_vs_morphos23.php), the reactions from "the red side" was a lot like what you wrote in the quote above; "It's unfair because it's not optimized, 3D will be better", etc, etc. Yada, yada. It never was, 3D is AFAIK pretty much the same, and here you are, cheering for new 3D technologies when Hyperion haven't even shown they can really support the old ones yet. Will you *never* learn I ask myself?

And then you write about SMP, Memory Barrier, etc, etc — lots of stuff that's completely incompatible to Amiga per se. Well, none of this is here, only more promises of more unhatched chickes. Things like true SMP, true MP, removal of the memory barrier/true utilization of the 64bit architecture is nothing you do easily on Amiga. In fact, it can't be done without breaking the "Amiga" part of the OS. And since this *will* require a clean-slate break from the Amiga legacy anyway (it must happen if you decide to go there), with a clearly defined border line marking the "before" and "after", the seemless "Amiga compatibility" with old Apps scrapped post that line, starting anew, I must ask the question:

At that point, why continue the PPC path at all? If you are to break the "Amiga" anyway, why not do it on some *other*/BETTER architecture? Performance wise, and from a desktop Point of View, x86 is much more attractive. Isn't a platform migration the natural thing to do at that point? There is no "Power" in PowerPC, not in the year 2012 and beyond! ARM and/or x86, but not PPC!

Isn't the $3,000 A1X1K *the worst possible* path to go if your goal is to introduce those things into the OS? After sacrificing the Amiga compatibility as we know it, you may (after long hard work) have reached the goals, but then you are *still stuck* on a dead platform, completely without viable motherboards, since there hasn't been any viable desktop motherboards manufactured since Apple dropped out of the PPC architecture half a decade ago, and there never will be! It would be AROS, but without any option of good hardware. You will have your platform chained to a sinking block of concrete. And you think that at $3,000 the concrete block should at least be gilded or something, but it isn't, it's just plain nothing out of the ordinary, old boring concrete from 2007, but it will drown your platform nevertheless...

(BTW: If you think this is going off topic, please feel free to direct your replies to this thread (http://www.amiga.org/forums/showthread.php?t=60755), which is entirely devoted to this issue, maybe by commenting post #4)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: takemehomegrandma on April 03, 2012, 09:24:59 AM
Quote from: AmigaNG;686731
this is no cheap hobby


It seems the hobby of you people is basically destroying good money...?

Quote
if you really want a cheap Amiga ng type of experices then I would personally recommend getting an old pc and installing Aros on it, not a PowerMac.


It would be interesting to hear how you can even compare MorphOS to AROS like they would be playing in the same league?
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: OlafS3 on April 03, 2012, 10:57:25 AM
you are my king. How can anyone compare with your knowledge. You play in another league too...
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: takemehomegrandma on April 03, 2012, 11:30:00 AM
Quote from: OlafS3;686736
you are my king. How can anyone compare with your knowledge. You play in another league too...

Instead of making pointless grumpy posts that just increases the noise, why not try to answer the question instead? (Edit) By "recommending getting an old pc and installing Aros on it, not a PowerMac", you are solely focusing on x86 hardware *for the sake of it*, totally neglecting the differences in features of the two OS's, which probably is the most important variable of them all for the user experience and *usability* at all. "An old PC" is hardly any cheaper than an old PowerMac, and if it's the user experience you want (i.e. really being able to *use* it as an Amiga), then MorphOS is the one NG solution that has the most to offer...
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: OlafS3 on April 03, 2012, 11:35:23 AM
because when you say Morphos is unbeatable and everywhere the best (Gallium?, poseidon is from Aros?, TCP is ArosTCP?, support of different processors?, drivers?, can be combined with Linux?, running on modern hardware? ...) what should we discuss?

And I forgot... Aros is years behind and Morphos plays in another league...

I personal enjoy this "years behind" running on X86 (Kubuntu) :-)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: takemehomegrandma on April 03, 2012, 11:45:06 AM
Quote from: OlafS3;686739
because when you say Morphos is unbeatable and everywhere the best (Gallium?, poseidon is from Aros?, TCP is ArosTCP?, support of different processors?, drivers?, can be combined with Linux?, running on modern hardware? ...) what should we discuss?


I fail to see what point you are trying to make? Do you think the ties between MorphOS and AROS is unknown to anyone? MorphOS has used (and also returned them to AROS in an evolved state) some AROS components over the years, but what has that to do with anything? (And I won't bother commenting the factual errors there...)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: OlafS3 on April 03, 2012, 11:47:05 AM
you can buy here used PC for 200 EUR including 3 GHz and 2 GB RAM. And of course you can buy new and much better hardware. At home I use a Notebook with 4 cores and 4 GB for 480 EUR (including Windows 7). So do not try to make a competition with hardware. Hardware is the weakest point of MorphOS (as for AmigaOS). Both stick with oldfashioned PowerPC.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: OlafS3 on April 03, 2012, 11:48:55 AM
MorphOS has modern 3D support? Have I missed something?

All camps have strength and weaknesses and none is "unbeatable" with no room for improvement

MorphOS versus Aros:
http://www.amiga.org/forums/showthread.php?t=61247

better to continue there if you like. This thread is (was) about X1000
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Iggy on April 03, 2012, 11:54:20 AM
Quote from: OlafS3;686742
MorphOS has modern 3D support? Have I missed something?
 
All camps have strength and weaknesses and none is "unbeatable" with no room for improvement

 
Am I missing something?
AROS doesn't support the latest 3D GPUs either.
An Nvidia 7600GT (like mine) or a 9600GSO? Sure.
Buy not much higher.
 
And compared to OS4, both MorphOSand AROS support adequate 3D support.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: OlafS3 on April 03, 2012, 11:59:35 AM
there is a new thread comparing Aros and Morphos:
http://www.amiga.org/forums/showthread.php?t=61247

the discussion here is off-topic
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: takemehomegrandma on April 03, 2012, 12:11:44 PM
Quote from: OlafS3;686742
This thread is (was) about X1000


Indeed it is!
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: AmigaNG on April 03, 2012, 02:00:15 PM
Quote from: takemehomegrandma;686738
Instead of making pointless grumpy posts that just increases the noise, why not try to answer the question instead? (Edit) By "recommending getting an old pc and installing Aros on it, not a PowerMac", you are solely focusing on x86 hardware *for the sake of it*, totally neglecting the differences in features of the two OS's, which probably is the most important variable of them all for the user experience and *usability* at all. "An old PC" is hardly any cheaper than an old PowerMac, and if it's the user experience you want (i.e. really being able to *use* it as an Amiga), then MorphOS is the one NG solution that has the most to offer...

So based on this post can you understand why people who are interested in getting an OS4 machine are a bit confused when you recommend a PowerMac on a AmigaOS4 related thread.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: takemehomegrandma on April 03, 2012, 02:20:04 PM
Quote from: AmigaNG;686774
So based on this post can you understand why people who are interested in getting an OS4 machine are a bit confused when you recommend a PowerMac on a AmigaOS4 related thread.


Not at all, that was settled in the original post already, everyone really interesting in getting an A1X1K knows exactly how to proceed from reading that single post! ;)

Anyone wanting to *learn more* however, to hear more than a single view on the HW (the "impartial" view of the seller), etc, is free to proceed reading the rest of the thread. And since $3,000 is far from a trivial amount of money, I think it's only fair to (as a complement) point out what you can actually get as an *alternative*, i.e. a system with roughly the same performance, running an OS with more and better features, better Amiga compatibility, higher stability, etc, for 1/30th of the asking price in the original post. It's a free world, if you absolutely want an A1X1K and have a pile of money that you stumble upon every time you walk into the kitchen, then there is nothing stopping you. But *maybe* you'll rethink and chose the other way, ending up with a *more competent* system overall, while still having some $2,800 left in the bank (depending on how much you "pimp" the HW)? I can think of *many* ways to use some left-over $2,800 personally, as I think most people can...

I get it that you don't like this, you have made it more than obvious...
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Iggy on April 03, 2012, 02:25:12 PM
Quote from: AmigaNG;686774
So based on this post can you understand why people who are interested in getting an OS4 machine are a bit confused when you recommend a PowerMac on a AmigaOS4 related thread.

Actually, that makes sense to me.
It would make more sense to reference Transitions offer on AmigaOne XE systems.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: klx300r on April 03, 2012, 03:05:49 PM
@ mods/ Transition

time to close this thread & stop posting OS4.1 news from amigans and amigaworld if you constantly allow this crap to get out of hand

@ mikeymike

thanks for the effort & just a reminder:
    Quote:
                                                      Originally Posted by mikeymike                (http://www.amiga.org/forums/web/buttons/viewpost.gif) (http://www.amiga.org/forums/showthread.php?p=686525#post686525)             
             ....  I'm trying to figure out why  you care so much that you regularly have to come here and troll, because  that's what you're doing.  Having said that, I think it's more likely  that you simply do it for your own amusement, hence your "who knows, who  cares" comment.
                         
 :drink:  mate I think you better save this response as you can save time by  cutting & pasting it into EVERY single OS4.x related thread on this  site.                                                                                          __________________
            

@ usual suspects

good job but you were slow to start this one. I'm expecting quicker service on the next OS4.x thread or you'll start losing troll cred:roflmao:
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: eliyahu on April 03, 2012, 03:05:52 PM
Quote from: Iggy;686779
Actually, that makes sense to me.
It would make more sense to reference Transitions offer on AmigaOne XE systems.
what offer are you referring to? i must have missed that one.

edit: never mind. found it. thanks.

-- eliyahu
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: drHirudo on April 03, 2012, 03:11:36 PM
Quote from: takemehomegrandma;686777
i.e. a system with roughly the same performance, running an OS with more and better features, better Amiga compatibility, higher stability, etc, for 1/30th of the asking price in the original post.


Either you are VERY BAD at mathematics or you talk about MacOS X, which comes for free with PowerMacs.

According to MorphOS Help Desk (http://www.morphos-team.net/faq), MorphOS keyfile is currently available at an price of 111.11 EUR (includes 19% VAT).
Googling todays (as Piru loves to use Google) EUR/USD conversion - 111.11 Euros = 147.94 USD.

So with 3000 USD, you can buy - 3000/147,94 - 20,27 MOS licenses (assuming you get the hardware for free).

So, your arithmetics are wrong and fabricated as usual, but this is nothing new in the MOS propaganda that floods the site all day long.

With X1000 you receive bundled copy of AmigaOS 4.1 - worth 124.95 Euro including VAT (http://www.vesalia.de/e_amigaos41.htm), and you are entitled for free copy of AmigaOS 4.2 when it arrives.
On top of that AmigaOS 4.1 comes in professional made box on labeled CD (something called collector's item for people like me who have all public AmigaOS versions on original disks, along with manuals, so it's worth for me).
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: fishy_fiz on April 03, 2012, 03:13:56 PM
Quote from: Iggy;686744
Am I missing something?
AROS doesn't support the latest 3D GPUs either.
An Nvidia 7600GT (like mine) or a 9600GSO? Sure.
Buy not much higher.
 
And compared to OS4, both MorphOSand AROS support adequate 3D support.


AROS works fine with up to gf5x0. My gtx570 worked in my AROS box when I had it (although more often as not performance wasnt as good as with the 9600gt that was the main card I used). Quality of 3d isnt soley dictated by cards supported either. The underlying subsystem plays a big part too.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: eliyahu on April 03, 2012, 03:15:57 PM
Quote from: drHirudo;686794
Either you are VERY BAD at mathematics or you talk about MacOS X, which comes for free with PowerMacs.

According to MorphOS Help Desk (http://www.morphos-team.net/faq), MorphOS keyfile is currently available at an price of 111.11 EUR (includes 19% VAT).
Googling todays (as Piru loves to use Google) EUR/USD conversion - 111.11 Euros = 147.94 USD.

So with 3000 USD, you can buy - 3000/147,94 - 20,27 MOS licenses (assuming you get the hardware for free).

So, your arithmetics are wrong and fabricated as usual, but this is nothing new in the MOS propaganda that floods the site all day long.

With X1000 you receive bundled copy of AmigaOS 4.1 - worth 124.95 Euro including VAT (http://www.vesalia.de/e_amigaos41.htm), and you are entitled for free copy of AmigaOS 4.2 when it arrives.
On top of that AmigaOS 4.1 comes in professional made box on labeled CD (something called collector's item for people like me who have all public AmigaOS versions on original disks, along with manuals, so it's worth for me).
just FYI, at least with the 'first contact' systems, you had to purchase the OS license additionally. the free copy of OS4 is the copy of OS4.2 when it ships.

-- eliyahu
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: vox on April 03, 2012, 03:21:29 PM
Quote from: takemehomegrandma;686733
Yeah, it's always this "is yet to be used", "might", "future", yada, yada. Anyone knowing Hyperion, should really know by now that they love to sell unhatched chickens with great promises, long before the chickens are hatched. Sometimes it turns out in the end that the eggs never was laid, and never will be. Was the Micro A1 GX ever sorted out/fully supported?
Will you *never* learn I ask myself?

original A1 board was supported including Altivec, only some problems with really defective USB I believe, but PCI cards with USB got full support. SAM 440 is fully supported by now (incl. FPGA) and only sadly SAM 460 support is lacking now. Yes, USB 2.0 took ages and didn`t give real fast results, it even took time to reach stability with update 4.
There are lot of things to be angry for (e.g. SAM 460 still having beta SATA, sound and RadeonHD with no 3D) but its also clear to see AmigaOS got more development, team leader, beta testing, website, forum etc. in last two years then ever before.

If there would be no SMP and 3D as well as other optimizations and drivers expected out of AmigaOS 4.2, there would be no need for X1000 at all. Single core G4 or AMCC 460 would be enough. I understand the frustration of releasing hardware first and then finalizing the drivers later, agreed I like the MorphOS approach of testing hardware and developing drivers first and then making public appearance. But there are no doubts X1000 (and SAM 460) drivers will be developed in time, assumingly with some driver release for OS 4.1 users and with initial OS 4.2

If there were no PCI-E PPC Amigas like SAM 460 and X1000 RadeonHD driver would not make much sense. MOS team builds only MorphOS and yet is late with MorphOS 3, while Hyperion does support and bugfixing of current AmigaOS 4.1, development of new features of OS 4.2 and Timberwolf simultaneously. Would love to see them throwing

All in one, nevermind the price, X1000 is attractive hardware for PPC Linux and AROS and should really drive AmigaOS 4 forward. Should be hardware viable for some MorphOS 3.x update - who has money to buy X1000 might have interest in paying 100 euros for "AmigaOS done well" IF it would fully support X1000 hardware. There is a place for MOS team to compete, and I am sure Trevor would donate a board for developers.

Any set dates for MorphOS 3? (none for OS 4.2)

So instead of attacking its price / performance side, use it to your best interest.

Surely there will be some solution for SMP in both MorphOS and AmigaOS 4.x. It might make 68k compatibility go away, but since such hardware as SAM 460, MacMini or X1000 should run 68k software well with JIT - that could not be a shame, but way forward. Before X1000 there was no need to consider it at all.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: number6 on April 03, 2012, 03:24:41 PM
Quote from: takemehomegrandma;686733
Yeah, it's always this "is yet to be used", "might", "future", yada, yada. Anyone knowing Hyperion, should really know by now that they love to sell unhatched chickens with great promises, long before the chickens are hatched. Sometimes it turns out in the end that the eggs never was laid, and never will be. Was the Micro A1 GX ever sorted out/fully supported?



Yes. 7 years ago.
Regardless, give credit to Eyetech on that one. They "supplied" the problem to Hyperion because they had no more supply of FX CPUs. Heh.

#6
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Fab on April 03, 2012, 03:34:29 PM
Quote from: vox;686801


MOS team builds only MorphOS and yet is late with MorphOS 3, while Hyperion does support and bugfixing of current AmigaOS 4.1, development of new features of OS 4.2 and Timberwolf simultaneously. Would love to see them throwing


If you go that way, MorphOS team also bugfixed 2.x and developped 3.x at the same time. Many of the developers of MorphOS team (including myself) have "pet" projects/applications beyond the core of MorphOS (that sometimes get integrated to MorphOS, course). And actually, Odyssey is part of MorphOS distribution.

Quote

Surely there will be some solution for SMP in both MorphOS and AmigaOS 4.x. It might make 68k compatibility go away, but since such hardware as SAM 460, MacMini or X1000 should run 68k software well with JIT - that could not be a shame, but way forward. Before X1000 there was no need to consider it at all.


If 68k compatibility has to be dropped, then going x86 is a much better solution, don't you think?

As for SMP, assuming it would be possible without breaking everything and/or having bad performance, MorphOS would also have another potential target with the dual G4 boards for PowerMacs, or the dual/quad G5s.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: drHirudo on April 03, 2012, 03:49:43 PM
Quote from: Fab;686806
snip


Haha, this thread wouldn't have been complete if Fab didn't join talking about the OWB and how advanced it is.

I hope OWB is not the reason for MorphOS 3 not being out yet.


Just like TimberWolf is not the reason for AmigaOS 4.2 is not out yet.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: vox on April 03, 2012, 03:55:45 PM
Quote from: eliyahu;686797
just FYI, at least with the 'first contact' systems, you had to purchase the OS license additionally. the free copy of OS4 is the copy of OS4.2 when it ships.

-- eliyahu


True and not true. Base price for X1000 doesn`t include the OS 4.1 licence to make promised 1700GBP price tag which is what Trevor gets but excludes everything else ... (excludes VAT, shipping and the OS, as well as more RAM as 2GB was first promise). But in reality for price of one OS licence you get both OS 4.1.5 now and OS 4.2 in the future.

This is just made to make system base price look cheaper and might change with final system just because OS 4.2 should be done by then as well as drivers for motherboard, rendering sound and network PCI cards not needed. This could open the space to make system a bit cheaper, or at least with OS included. That, or higher order rate for batch. But not too much anyway.

But one thing is right: $3000 price calculated for X1000 includes VAT, AmigaOS and shipping while cheap ebay prices of MacMinis exclude shipping and MorphOS licence making not such a huge difference, rendering ratio almost to half.

Also, the trick is in comparing new and used hardware. Surely, you could get 4-5 SAM 440 766-800Mhz systems used for price of X1000 running AmigaOS 4 but they would not perform not even close to it. But maybe 3-4 A1 or Peg2 systems that would perform 20-30% slower.

But what if people want expand ability, and ability to use dual core in the future and only X1000 offers it?
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: vox on April 03, 2012, 04:06:30 PM
Quote from: Fab;686806
If you go that way, MorphOS team also bugfixed 2.x and developped 3.x at the same time. Many of the developers of MorphOS team (including myself) have "pet" projects/applications beyond the core of MorphOS (that sometimes get integrated to MorphOS, course). And actually, Odyssey is part of MorphOS distribution.  


Haven`t heard of anything new after 2.7, and 3 was announced afterwards. OK, having similar situation should help the understanding why some things are not yet done. MorphOS is done better, surely, but has longer career of development and no frozen time of court case. We are all looking forward to see how OS 4.2 (and MorphOS 3) will improve and yes, will difference increase or decrease at least on Peg2 (I don`t expect OS 4 to become superior soon).

It is a said fact that beyond Blizzard cards (MOS 1.x, AOS 4.1) and Peg 2 (MOS 2.x, AOS 4.1) there are no more PPC systems supported by both.
Or even better OS4 Emu and kind of MOS Emu wrappers or some code trade-offs (e.g. Ambient for OS4). Having OS4 reached MUI4 compatibility was a great thing and brought MUI OWB (thanks for OWB development!)

Quote from: Fab;686806
If 68k compatibility has to be dropped, then going x86 is a much better solution, don't you think?  


Woud like both to evolve to x86 board with RadeonHD cards and some newer Sound Blaster. At least MorphOS team and Hyperion would prove to be software only companies looking to offer OS to wider hardware base. But meanwhile, buying what is available is only option.

[QUOTEAs for SMP, assuming it would be possible without breaking everything and/or having bad performance, MorphOS would also have another potential
target with the dual G4 boards for PowerMacs, or the dual/quad G5s.[/QUOTE]

Would love to see MorphOS (and OS4, PPC Linux, AROS) using Mac G5.
Cheap and mighty!
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: takemehomegrandma on April 03, 2012, 04:21:18 PM
@ drHirudo

After everything that has been said in this thread (and even illustrated with pictures) about money and "worth for money", it's actually rather amusing to see you trying playing ball in "the numbers game" this way! :lol: Nothing you say, no matter what numbers you put up here for comparison, will make the A1X1K look like a good buy, or even *sane*... ;)

Quote
So with 3000 USD, you can buy - 3000/147,94 - 20,27 MOS licenses


But I honestly think most people will settle with just one! :p ;) I'm sorry to say, but you seem to have *entirely* missed the point...

Quote from: eliyahu;686797
just FYI, at least with the 'first contact' systems, you had to purchase the OS license additionally.


See...? :) And the MorphOS price for licenses for some older HW is said to go down... *in the future*! ;) (Just like on OS4: everything will be good, and everything will be supported... *in the future* :lol:)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: takemehomegrandma on April 03, 2012, 04:53:46 PM
Quote from: vox;686808
But in reality for price of one OS licence you get both OS 4.1.5 now and OS 4.2 in the future.


Isn't that pretty much exactly what eliyahu said? :lol:

Quote
But what if people want expand ability


Plenty of room in a PowerMac...

Quote
and ability to use dual core in the future and only X1000 offers it?


So does the PowerMac!

But again, Amiga is a single core system, its design prevents true SMP, and it can't have true memory protection, and it isn't 64-bit either. *If* exploring these features would be the goal for the OS developers, then why on earth would they do it on a A1X1K? Why continue the PPC path at all? If you are to break the "Amiga" anyway, why not do it on some other, much better architecture? Even ARM seems to beat PPC! Performance wise, and from a desktop Point of View, x86 is even more attractive.

Isn't a platform migration the natural thing to do at that point? There is no "Power" in PowerPC, not in the year 2012 and beyond! ARM and/or x86, but not PPC! Since those features would require a break from the past, why continue with PPC at all? Why not bring the new platform onto a modern architecture? For example, if MorphOS developers would want to start exploring 64-bit support for the future (as suggested by Fab in his presentation of MorphOS future), why would they do that on a *dead* G5 platform (or PA6T for that matter)? I mean, if the legacy is to be broken anyway, why not migrate to greener pastures while you are at it?
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: itix on April 03, 2012, 05:04:03 PM
@drHirudo

FYI Odyssey a.k.a. MUIOWB is the most popular browser for Amiga.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: billyfish on April 03, 2012, 05:08:16 PM
Quote from: itix;686820
@drHirudo

FYI Odyssey a.k.a. MUIOWB is the most popular browser for Amiga.


Really?? I think it's a fine piece of work and hats off to Fab and co for it, but for example netsurf-m68k has 13760 downloads. Don't you think that there are more classic systems (especially including amikit, etc.) and consequently it's 68k-based browsers that are in use the most. Checking the logs of places such as here, amigaword, amigans, will give a better indication I guess.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: billyfish on April 03, 2012, 05:18:39 PM
Quote from: takemehomegrandma;686819

Isn't a platform migration the natural thing to do at that point? There is no "Power" in PowerPC, not in the year 2012 and beyond! ARM and/or x86, but not PPC! Since those features would require a break from the past, why continue with PPC at all? Why not bring the new platform onto a modern architecture? For example, if MorphOS developers would want to start exploring 64-bit support for the future (as suggested by Fab in his presentation of MorphOS future), why would they do that on a *dead* G5 platform (or PA6T for that matter)? I mean, if the legacy is to be broken anyway, why not migrate to greener pastures while you are at it?


It depends upon what your starting point is. Bear in mind x86 is little-endian and AFAIK arm processors are bi-endian.

I still haven't got a simple answer on why you care so much if someone buys an x1000. It's their money and to be honest if you turn my question on its head, why do you think they should care what your opinion is? You're happy with MorphOS on PowerMacs? Great, simply enjoy it then. I pity your poor wife/gf/partner if they have the audacity to pick a different brand of orange juice to the one you like and you bang on about it like this for 20 years! :-)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: itix on April 03, 2012, 05:31:49 PM
Quote from: billyfish;686821
Really?? I think it's a fine piece of work and hats off to Fab and co for it, but for example netsurf-m68k has 13760 downloads. Don't you think that there are more classic systems (especially including amikit, etc.) and consequently it's 68k-based browsers that are in use the most. Checking the logs of places such as here, amigaword, amigans, will give a better indication I guess.


Yes you might be right on that. Although... never mind, lets discuss it on another thread another time :)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: vox on April 03, 2012, 06:14:44 PM
Quote from: takemehomegrandma;686819

Isn't a platform migration the natural thing to do at that point? There is no "Power" in PowerPC, not in the year 2012 and beyond! ARM and/or x86, but not PPC! Since those features would require a break from the past, why continue with PPC at all? Why not bring the new platform onto a modern architecture? For example, if MorphOS developers would want to start exploring 64-bit support for the future (as suggested by Fab in his presentation of MorphOS future), why would they do that on a *dead* G5 platform (or PA6T for that matter)? I mean, if the legacy is to be broken anyway, why not migrate to greener pastures while you are at it?


There is still enough power in POWER in 2012, wouldn`t dismiss something living and developing. Is it a top leader? NO. Is it developed and usable. YES. Somehow just like AOS and MOS :-)

Forgot to mention X1000 is first platform to offer 64-bit transition path to AmigaOS. In my opinion, its more likely both advanced features might first be used on existing PPC systems being X1000 and likely G5 for MorphOS then we know of any real x86 transition.

Surely, would be happy at least to see some PPC emulation box for masculine and overpowered x86 multicore systems before the transition could be over. So all those arguing FOR the transition should think of bounty to get Apple Rosetta PPC emulator or to fund QEMMU / PearPC or some "Amithlon" kind of emulation box as emulation solution before the full port OR a realistic estimation would be what time is needed for other CPU port.

OS should develop meanwhile, and Hyperion decided to team up with new hardware. Hope they will do the net top as portable Miggy and low cost one, so the range can be from reasonable to heavy priced X1000.

If development should be continued on PPC and SMP introduced, next cheap and mighty thing are Playstations 3: soon will be replaced by PS4 and have enough horsepower to be a good computer.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Fats on April 03, 2012, 07:20:11 PM
Quote from: itix;686613
Didnt you piss off OS4 core developers on that Timberwolf thread at AWN...?


I think we are still on speaking terms. At least I am.
But then I am a weird person.

greets,
Staf.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Iggy on April 03, 2012, 08:44:04 PM
Quote from: Fats;686834
I think we are still on speaking terms. At least I am.
But then I am a weird person.

greets,
Staf.

Maybe you are, but I'm huddling in a corner of my home waiting for two seriously pissed off Germans to knock on my door.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Iggy on April 03, 2012, 08:45:55 PM
Quote from: vox;686828
Forgot to mention X1000 is first platform to offer 64-bit transition path to AmigaOS. In my opinion, its more likely both advanced features might first be used on existing PPC systems being X1000 and likely G5 for MorphOS then we know of any real x86 transition.

Maybe, but for now you're going to see these processors running in 32bit mode.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: amigacooke on April 03, 2012, 09:41:50 PM
Quote from: takemehomegrandma;686819
Isn't a platform migration the natural thing to do at that point? There is no "Power" in PowerPC, not in the year 2012 and beyond! ARM and/or x86, but not PPC! Since those features would require a break from the past, why continue with PPC at all? Why not bring the new platform onto a modern architecture? For example, if MorphOS developers would want to start exploring 64-bit support for the future (as suggested by Fab in his presentation of MorphOS future), why would they do that on a *dead* G5 platform (or PA6T for that matter)? I mean, if the legacy is to be broken anyway, why not migrate to greener pastures while you are at it?
Clearly the only sensible option is to migrate to modern operating systems with plenty of software support. Take your choice Windows, OS X or Linux.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Fats on April 03, 2012, 10:25:40 PM
Quote from: Iggy;686846
Maybe you are, but I'm huddling in a corner of my home waiting for two seriously pissed off Germans to knock on my door.


Iggy, sometimes you also act a little bit weird. You know ?
;)

Staf.
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Kesa on April 03, 2012, 10:34:15 PM
Wait. If X means 10 in roman and K is 1000 does'nt A1X1K expand out to Amiga 10 1000?   :(
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: billyfish on April 04, 2012, 11:52:39 AM
Quote from: itix;686824
Yes you might be right on that. Although... never mind, lets discuss it on another thread another time :)


Deal! Over a pint! :-)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: matt3k on April 04, 2012, 12:07:07 PM
Quote from: fishy_fiz;686603
[country hick accent]
We dont want none o' your kind 'round here. We calls 'em "logicals" an' they aint fit in with us NG ameegans
[/country hick accent]

translation:
That makes way too much sense for this place :)

Thanks for the great laugh Fiz....


Matt
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: billyfish on April 04, 2012, 12:33:40 PM
Quote from: fishy_fiz;686591
Firstly, I have no interest in NG "amiga" options anymore. If I want a machine to deal with the modern world, I'll use a modern machine, simple as that (and I'll get it for cheaper than either OS4 or MOS' cost of entry). Now I say this so people are under no illusions as to my agenda. This said:

This is an amiga website. There's few outside eyes watching. People know what theyre buying into, they know the stories, they know prices/pros/cons.

Do all the clowns that keep posting the same **** over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over (yes, its excessive to type the same thing so often, but some people think this is normal) is enlightening anyone? Do they think theyre providing any revalations? Are they really so stupid as to think people dont see right through any feeble attempts to cover thier real agenda? People who are interested in something arent going to be swayed by people so transparent they irritate even those with no interest. Want to promote your system of choice? Great, but these negative tactics lose any value pretty quickly, to a point that any interest someone originally had in the product promoted by those using negative tactics also fades pretty quickly.

Personally I love my a1200 still. It cost me a pretty penny to upgrade it to a point its on par with a mac or pc Id have thown away 15 years ago, but guess what? I dont give a ****, it's my hobby and I enjoy it. No amount ot negativity from strangers who by now sound either like turrets sufferers stuck on a groove, or mentally challenged will change that.

This isnt to say I dont find some benchmarks interesting, I do, but there's only so many times a person can find a tenuous segue and repeat the same thing before they make people like me lose interest (someone who was previously interested in all amiga options until the community changed his mind with all the bull****(and make no mistake this isnt just one camp either)).

So no, youre not "informing people", youre doing damage and making the amiga scene appear as screwed up as it really is.


Totally agree, though I think you missed out a couple of "and over"'s :-)
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: loony on April 04, 2012, 12:43:08 PM
Sheesh...... :O

Been a few years since I posted on here...

came to see what the "New Amiga" I saw stories for, was all about..!!!! :/

Begining to wonder if I can post here now without getting a "Large Handbag" ;)


Really do need to get my 'Miggy' updated,
A 1200 with an accelerator and its "Massive" 1gig drive seem a bit out of it... after all these years....
Havent even managed to get the thing online yet "Still use the PeeSea for that" :O

Here's hoping for an upgrade I can afford realy soon...

laters Chaps
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: takemehomegrandma on April 04, 2012, 12:49:08 PM
@ loony

LOL, 3 posts in 8 years, that must be the *definition* of a "lurcher"... :lol:
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: WotTheFook on April 04, 2012, 08:15:45 PM
Quote from: mikeymike;686572
LOL, it's like Burma here isn't it.  However do you manage to keep up your heroic efforts and spirits in the face of all this oppression.


Actually, taking the CUSA questions thread and the censorship into account, it's more like Syria in here these days...
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Middleman on April 04, 2012, 08:30:48 PM
Folks,

Haywire...Duce et al, please calm down......your fears are unfounded.

I've just received an email from Barry tonight, and he has said he will answer ALL the questions and posts posed to him. Not ONE question on the thread is going to be removed or censored. He will answer them as best he can in his own time. So please be patient....

thanks,


Middleman


Quote from: Duce;687040
Sorry, Middleman.  Do your homework, and for God's sakes either disclose if you have an official relationship business wise with C-USA, or quit speaking for them.  We already have one Dammy, we don't need another.  


OK Duce, well you've asked me a question, so I'll answer it for you here. No I don't have ANY business relationship with Barry or CUSA at all, professional, personal or otherwise. I was approached by Transition to pass a message onto Barry to invite him over for this discussion. That's all I've done...
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Akiko on April 04, 2012, 08:37:48 PM
@Middleman

Sure your posing in the right thread?
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: klx300r on April 05, 2012, 12:03:31 AM
talk of apple products is sad enough now CUSA in this thread too:uzi::smack::flak:
Title: Re: Registering Interest for AmigaOne X1000
Post by: Pyromania on April 06, 2012, 01:53:03 PM
Why is no red case available?